Unit 9: Public Administration mind map
Unit 9 of UGC NET Political Science is Public Administration. It covers how the field began, the classical and human relations thinkers, bureaucracy, organisation theory, comparative and development administration, and New Public Management. Questions mostly ask which thinker wrote which book, who said a line, the order of events, or which statements about a theory are correct. This map teaches each idea in plain words and puts the names, books and orders into tables. Each concept gives crisp points, a simple explanation, an everyday example, a table to memorise and a short self-test. Everything comes from past UGC NET Political Science papers.
Short of time? Start with Classical and scientific management. It carries the most questions (62). Use the List view tab for a fast read the night before the exam.
All the notes in one place
This is the same content as the map, written out so you can read it from top to bottom. Open a branch to read it.
🏛️ Growth of the discipline
How public administration began with Wilson, how its stages and approaches changed, and how New Public Administration asked for relevance and equity.
Beginnings and landmarks
Wilson and The Study of Administration
Woodrow Wilson's 1887 essay started public administration as a separate field of study.
- Title: The Study of Administration, in Political Science Quarterly, 1887.
- Administration is a field of business, away from the strife of politics.
- This idea is the politics-administration dichotomy.
- Line: it is getting harder to run a constitution than to frame one.
- He urged America to learn from European, mainly Prussian and French, methods.
Wilson was a professor and later President of the United States. He argued that governments had spent long on framing constitutions but little on running them well. So he asked for a science of administration, free of party politics. His essay is treated as the birth of the discipline.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Author | Woodrow Wilson |
| Year | 1887 |
| Journal | Political Science Quarterly |
| Main idea | Politics-administration dichotomy |
Test yourself: Who wrote the 1887 paper The Study of Administration?
- Henri Fayol
- Woodrow Wilson
- Mary Parker Follett
- Max Weber
Answer: B. Wilson published it in Political Science Quarterly in 1887.
Dwight Waldo and his works
Dwight Waldo questioned the dichotomy and the search for principles. His books are common match items.
- The Administrative State, 1948: administration as political theory.
- Ideas and Issues in Public Administration, 1953.
- The Study of Public Administration, 1955.
- Democracy, Bureaucracy and Hypocrisy, 1977.
- He convened Minnowbrook in 1968 and edited the 1971 Turbulence volume.
Waldo said public administration cannot be value-neutral because it serves a democratic society. His 1948 book argued that administration is also a kind of political theory. He later became the elder voice of the new generation of scholars who wanted relevance.
| Book | Year |
|---|---|
| The Administrative State | 1948 |
| Ideas and Issues in Public Administration | 1953 |
| The Study of Public Administration | 1955 |
| Democracy, Bureaucracy and Hypocrisy | 1977 |
Test yourself: Who wrote Democracy, Bureaucracy and Hypocrisy?
- Fred Riggs
- Dwight Waldo
- Rensis Likert
- Abraham Maslow
Answer: B. It is Waldo's 1977 book on the tension between democratic ideals and bureaucratic practice.
Minnowbrook, Philadelphia and the new generation
Conferences of the late 1960s pushed public administration toward relevance. Their order is often asked.
- Urwick, The Elements of Administration: 1943.
- Philadelphia Conference on the theory and practice of public administration: 1967.
- First Minnowbrook Conference: 1968.
- Waldo's volume Public Administration in a Time of Turbulence: 1971.
Young scholars felt that the old field ignored race riots, poverty and the war in Vietnam. The Honey Report of 1967 on higher education for public service and the Philadelphia Conference came first. Minnowbrook at Syracuse University followed in 1968. Minnowbrook II in 1988 was a later review, not the origin.
| Event | Year |
|---|---|
| Urwick, Elements of Administration | 1943 |
| Philadelphia Conference | 1967 |
| First Minnowbrook Conference | 1968 |
| Public Administration in a Time of Turbulence | 1971 |
Test yourself: Which came first?
- Minnowbrook Conference
- Philadelphia Conference
- Waldo's Turbulence volume
- Urwick's Elements of Administration
Answer: D. Urwick's book is from 1943, long before the 1960s events.
Church, military and people's participation
Early models of hierarchy came from the church and the army. People take part in administration through formal and informal modes.
- The church and the military shaped early administrative theory.
- They gave hierarchy, discipline and chain of command.
- Formal modes of participation: election, referendum, initiative and recall.
- Revolutions fall outside the constitution, so they are not a formal mode.
Writers on administrative history point out that scalar chain, unity of command and line and staff were borrowed from the Catholic hierarchy and the army. Formal participation means channels that the constitution or law provides. Recall lets voters remove an elected representative before the term ends.
Test yourself: Which two institutions shaped early administrative theory most?
- Schools and NGOs
- The church and the military
- Markets and families
- Revolutions and elections
Answer: B. Hierarchy and discipline came from them.
First Administrative Reforms Commission
India's first Administrative Reforms Commission began in January 1966 to review the machinery of government.
- Set up on 5 January 1966.
- First chairman: Morarji Desai.
- K. Hanumanthaiya took over when Desai became Deputy Prime Minister.
- It recommended the Lokpal and Lokayukta institutions.
- The Second ARC came in 2005.
The commission studied the working of central and state administration and gave about twenty reports. Its best-known recommendation for citizens was an ombudsman-type body, the Lokpal at the Centre and Lokayuktas in the states.
| Commission | Year | Chairman |
|---|---|---|
| First ARC | 1966 | Morarji Desai, then K. Hanumanthaiya |
| Second ARC | 2005 | M. Veerappa Moily |
Test yourself: When was the First Administrative Reforms Commission set up?
- 9 January 1965
- 5 January 1966
- 21 May 1966
- 17 March 1966
Answer: B. It was appointed on 5 January 1966.
Administrative reform committees in order
India's reform bodies came in a set order. Ayyangar came first and the Satish Chandra Committee last.
- Gopalaswamy Ayyangar Committee: 1949, machinery of government.
- Gorwala Committee: 1951, integrity and quality of the civil service.
- First Administrative Reforms Commission: 1966-70, first Morarji Desai, then K. Hanumanthaiya.
- Satish Chandra Committee: 1989, civil services examination.
The Ayyangar report shaped the central secretariat. The First ARC gave 20 reports and proposed the Lokpal and Lokayukta. Paul Appleby's reports of 1953 and 1956 lie between the Gorwala Committee and the First ARC.
| Body | Year |
|---|---|
| Gopalaswamy Ayyangar | 1949 |
| Gorwala Committee | 1951 |
| First ARC | 1966-70 |
| Satish Chandra Committee | 1989 |
Test yourself: Which body came first?
- Gorwala Committee
- Satish Chandra Committee
- Gopalaswamy Ayyangar Committee
- First ARC
Answer: C. The Ayyangar Committee reported in 1949.
IIPA, the District Magistrate and US landmarks
The Indian Institute of Public Administration was set up in March 1954 as a think tank. Several US landmarks were matched too.
- IIPA: New Delhi, March 1954, after Appleby's report of 1953.
- District Magistrate: role changed mainly through democratic decentralisation.
- Pendleton Act 1883 created the US Civil Service Commission.
- First Hoover Commission 1947-49 raised managerial capacity of the President's office.
Under the colonial system the Collector handled law and order and revenue. Community development and Panchayati Raj gave him a developmental role. The Hawthorne studies dealt with work environment and productivity.
| Item | Link |
|---|---|
| IIPA | March 1954 |
| Pendleton Act | US Civil Service Commission |
| First Hoover Commission | Managerial capacity of the President |
| Hawthorne studies | Work environment |
Test yourself: When was the Indian Institute of Public Administration set up?
- January 1950
- February 1951
- April 1953
- March 1954
Answer: D. It was set up in New Delhi in March 1954.
Public and private administration compared
Several writers hold that public and private administration differ. Appleby's line is that government is different.
- Paul Appleby: government is wider, more political and more accountable.
- Appleby's book Big Democracy (1945) carries the idea.
- Herbert Simon and Josiah Stamp also pointed to differences.
- L. D. White is not in that group.
A government office answers to the public and the legislature, and a firm answers to its owners. The keyed group is Appleby, Simon and Stamp.
| Writer | View |
|---|---|
| Paul Appleby | Government is different |
| Herbert Simon | Differences exist |
| Josiah Stamp | Differences exist |
| L. D. White | Not in the group |
Test yourself: Who held that government administration is different from private management?
- Paul Appleby
- Taylor
- Fayol
- Mayo
Answer: A. Appleby's Big Democracy stressed the political setting.
Definitions and stages
Definitions of public administration
Each writer defines public administration in a different way. Questions give the line and ask for the author.
- Waldo: the art and science of management applied to the affairs of state.
- L. D. White: management of men and materials to accomplish the purposes of the state.
- Pfiffner and Presthus: coordination of individual and group efforts to carry out public policy.
- Dimock and Dimock: a phrase on politically determined objectives is also linked with them.
All definitions show administration as the carrying out of public purposes. White stresses men and materials. Pfiffner and Presthus stress coordination of effort. Waldo's wording joins art and science.
| Author | Key words in the definition |
|---|---|
| L. D. White | Management of men and materials |
| Pfiffner and Presthus | Coordination of efforts to carry out policy |
| Waldo | Art and science of management |
Test yourself: Who defined public administration as the art and science of management applied to the affairs of state?
- L. D. White
- Herbert Simon
- Dwight Waldo
- Pfiffner and Presthus
Answer: C. This is Waldo's wording.
Stages in the evolution of the field
Scholars divide the growth of public administration into stages. The names and years are matched in exams.
- Politics-administration dichotomy: 1887-1926.
- Principles of administration: 1927-1937.
- Era of challenges: 1938-1947.
- Crisis of identity: 1948-1970.
- Exploratory period in another scheme: 1887-1910.
The dichotomy stage starts with Wilson. The principles stage is the golden era of Willoughby, Gulick and Urwick. Challenges came from Simon, Waldo and the human relations school. Then the field lost its clear identity. In a different scheme the first stage up to 1910 is called the exploratory period.
| Stage | Period |
|---|---|
| Politics-administration dichotomy | 1887-1926 |
| Principles of administration | 1927-1937 |
| Era of challenges | 1938-1947 |
| Crisis of identity | 1948-1970 |
Test yourself: Which stage covers 1927-1937?
- Era of challenges
- Crisis of identity
- Principles of administration
- Politics-administration dichotomy
Answer: C. Those years are the golden era of principles.
Nicholas Henry's six paradigms
Nicholas Henry described six paradigms of public administration. The order is a favourite question.
- Paradigm 1: politics-administration dichotomy.
- Paradigm 2: principles of administration.
- Paradigm 3: challenge to the dichotomy.
- Paradigm 4: public administration as political science.
- Paradigm 5: public administration as management or administrative science.
- Paradigm 6: public administration as public administration.
Paradigms 4 and 5 overlap in time. The field first went back toward political science, then toward management science. From 1970 it began to call itself public administration, with its own focus.
| Order | Paradigm |
|---|---|
| 1 | Politics-administration dichotomy |
| 2 | Principles of administration |
| 4 | Public administration as political science |
| 5 | Public administration as administrative science |
| 6 | Public administration as public administration |
Test yourself: Which Henry paradigm comes last?
- Public administration as political science
- Principles of administration
- Politics-administration dichotomy
- Public administration as public administration
Answer: D. The field began to stand on its own from about 1970.
Classical, human relations and behavioural approaches
Several approaches study the same field in different ways. Each has a one-line identity.
- Structural or classical: economy, efficiency and formal structure.
- Human relations: relations among people at work.
- Behavioural: use of behavioural science to study behaviour in organisations.
- Political economy: economic methods and models applied to political problems.
- Development is the theme of development administration, not of the behavioural approach.
Classical theory, from Taylor, Fayol, Gulick, Urwick and Weber, gave administration its first set of concepts and said it is a separate activity. The behavioural approach borrows from psychology, sociology and anthropology. It studies motivation, leadership, communication and groups.
| Approach | Focus |
|---|---|
| Structural | Economy and efficiency |
| Human relations | Relations among workers |
| Behavioural | Behavioural science in organisations |
| Political economy | Economic models for political problems |
Test yourself: What does the behavioural approach mean in the study of organisation?
- Study of the organisation chart
- Study of one civil servant
- Use of behavioural science to study organisational behaviour
- Study of development goals
Answer: C. It applies psychology and sociology to behaviour at work.
Simon and the principles as proverbs
Herbert Simon attacked the classical principles of administration. He called them proverbs.
- The article was The Proverbs of Administration, 1946.
- The book was Administrative Behavior, 1947.
- For every principle there is an equally good opposite one.
- He made decision-making the heart of administration.
Simon showed that sayings like look before you leap and he who hesitates is lost point in opposite directions. In the same way, principles such as unity of command and specialisation can clash. So they guide poorly. He asked for a science built on decisions.
Test yourself: Why did Simon reject the principles of administration?
- He thought they were laws
- He said they are only proverbs
- He accepted them fully
- He wrote them himself
Answer: B. For almost every principle an opposite one sounds equally good.
Thinkers matched with books
Match lists give authors and their books. A few titles repeat across papers.
- Appleby: Morality and Administration in Democratic Government.
- Gaus, White and Dimock: The Frontiers of Public Administration.
- Willoughby: Principles of Public Administration.
- Lerner and Lasswell: The Policy Sciences.
- Dahl: The Science of Public Administration, Three Problems.
Willoughby's 1927 book is a landmark of the classical school. Dahl's 1947 essay said a pure science of administration is not possible without studying culture and values. Simon's 1947 book proposed decisions as the base. Match by author, not by how modern the title sounds.
| Author | Book |
|---|---|
| Willoughby | Principles of Public Administration (1927) |
| Simon | Administrative Behavior (1947) |
| Dahl | The Science of Public Administration (1947) |
| Lerner and Lasswell | The Policy Sciences |
Test yourself: Who wrote Principles of Public Administration?
- W. F. Willoughby
- Herbert Simon
- Robert Dahl
- Paul Appleby
Answer: A. It is Willoughby's 1927 work.
Thinkers in time order
Some papers ask for thinkers in order of time. A short date list settles them.
- Weber lived 1864-1920.
- Willoughby wrote his Principles in 1927.
- Elton Mayo ran the Hawthorne studies in the 1920s and 1930s.
- Easton wrote The Political System in 1953.
- Birth years: Fayol 1841, Follett 1868, Barnard 1886, Waldo 1913.
In one question, the right order was Weber, Willoughby, Mayo and Easton. In another, by year of birth, it was Fayol, Follett, Barnard and Waldo. When a name is unfamiliar, place it using the book or experiment that made it known.
| Thinker | Born |
|---|---|
| Henri Fayol | 1841 |
| Mary Parker Follett | 1868 |
| Chester Barnard | 1886 |
| Dwight Waldo | 1913 |
Test yourself: Who was born first?
- Chester Barnard
- Henri Fayol
- Mary Parker Follett
- Dwight Waldo
Answer: B. Fayol was born in 1841.
Approaches matched with their key ideas
Approaches are matched with one key idea each. Learn the pairs once.
- Behavioural: analysis of human behaviour in administration.
- Bureaucratic: legal-rational authority (Weber).
- Ecological: agraria-transitia-industria (Riggs).
- General systems: sub-system of society, negative feedback.
The decision-making approach of Simon separates fact from value. The ecological approach studies administration in its social setting. General systems theory holds that a system corrects itself through feedback.
| Approach | Key idea |
|---|---|
| Ecological | Agraria-Industria |
| Decision-making | Fact-value |
| Bureaucratic | Legal-rational |
| General systems | Negative feedback |
Test yourself: Which approach goes with legal-rational authority?
- Ecological
- Bureaucratic
- Behavioural
- Decision-making
Answer: B. Weber's bureaucracy rests on legal-rational authority.
Henry's stages with dates
Nicholas Henry's stages run from 1887 to 1970 in four steps. Their order and years are asked.
- Politics-administration dichotomy: 1887-1926.
- Principles of administration: 1927-1937.
- Era of challenge: 1938-1947.
- Crisis of identity: 1948-1970.
Wilson's essay of 1887 opens the first stage. Gulick and Urwick belong to the second, and Simon's attack on the principles to the third. The field lost its separate identity in the fourth. Public policy perspective follows.
| Stage | Period |
|---|---|
| Dichotomy | 1887-1926 |
| Principles | 1927-1937 |
| Challenge | 1938-1947 |
| Crisis of identity | 1948-1970 |
Test yourself: Which stage ran from 1938 to 1947?
- Dichotomy
- Principles
- Era of challenge
- Crisis of identity
Answer: C. Henry's era of challenge.
New Public Administration
What New Public Administration stands for
New Public Administration came from the Minnowbrook Conference of 1968. It wants a value-based, equity-seeking field.
- Four key words: relevance, values, equity and change.
- It is anti-positivist, anti-technical and anti-hierarchical.
- It is not anti-values. It stands for social equity.
- Leaders: Dwight Waldo and H. George Frederickson.
- Focus on norms and client loyalty.
Young scholars disliked a value-neutral administration that served the powerful. They asked administrators to take the side of the weak, to act on social problems and to accept change. Frederickson later wrote on citizen responsiveness and on worker and citizen participation in decisions.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Born at | Minnowbrook Conference, 1968 |
| Keywords | Relevance, values, equity, change |
| Anti goals | Positivism, technical outlook, hierarchy |
| Leader names | Waldo, Frederickson |
Test yourself: Which are the anti goals of New Public Administration?
- Anti-positivism, anti-technical, anti-values
- Anti-positivism, anti-technical, anti-hierarchy
- Anti-hierarchy, anti-values only
- All four including anti-values
Answer: B. It is against positivism, narrow technique and rigid hierarchy, but for values.
Rational choice and the golden era
Two more labels appear in match lists. Rational choice and the golden era have clear markers.
- Rational choice: people act as self-interested utility maximisers.
- It encourages research in policy analysis.
- It has influenced organisational behaviour, local government and the theory of democratic administration.
- Golden era: about 1927-1937, devising principles and laws.
Rational choice uses economic ideas on public bodies. It asks how individuals pick among options in an office or a local council. The golden era is the age of Gulick and Urwick, who looked for universal principles of organisation.
| Label | Feature |
|---|---|
| Rational choice | Policy analysis research |
| New Public Administration | Norms and client loyalty |
| New Public Management | Private sector practices |
| Golden era | Principles and laws of administration |
Test yourself: Which approach emulates private sector practices?
- Golden era
- Rational choice
- New Public Administration
- New Public Management
Answer: D. Management ideas from business are the mark of New Public Management.
Marini, Minnowbrook 1968 and Ostrom
The first Minnowbrook Conference met in 1968. Frank Marini summed up its five themes.
- Minnowbrook I: 1968, Syracuse University, convened by Dwight Waldo.
- Marini's five heads: relevance, values, social equity, change, client-focus.
- Marini edited Toward a New Public Administration (1971).
- Vincent Ostrom's The Intellectual Crisis in American Public Administration (1973) deals with public choice.
Young scholars rejected value-free efficiency. Later conferences came in 1988 and 2008. Ostrom rejected the Wilson-Weber single hierarchy and asked for many overlapping centres of decision.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Minnowbrook I | 1968 |
| Marini's themes | Five heads |
| Ostrom's book | Public choice |
| Later conferences | 1988, 2008 |
Test yourself: Who summarised New Public Administration under five heads?
- Waldo
- Taylor
- Frank Marini
- Follett
Answer: C. Marini edited the Minnowbrook volume.
⚙️ Classical and scientific management
Taylor's science of work, Fayol's general theory, Gulick's POSDCORB, Urwick's principles and Follett's view of coordination.
Scientific management
Taylor and scientific management
Frederick W. Taylor is the father of scientific management. He wanted a true science of work.
- Book: The Principles of Scientific Management, 1911.
- Time and motion studies, standard tools, piece-rate pay.
- Aim: a fair day's work for a fair day's pay.
- His four principles: science, selection, cooperation, equal division of work.
- Problems that he faced: no work standards, unclear duties, rule-of-thumb choices.
Taylor worked in factories and saw that workers held back output and managers guessed. He replaced guesswork with measurement. Proper job design and pay incentives were his answers, not the causes of his theory.
| Problem before Taylor | Taylor's answer |
|---|---|
| No work standards | Time and motion study |
| Unclear duties | Division of responsibility |
| Rule-of-thumb decisions | Scientific methods |
Test yourself: Who is the father of scientific management?
- Henri Fayol
- Elton Mayo
- Frederick Taylor
- Max Weber
Answer: C. Taylor wrote the 1911 book that founded the movement.
Taylor's mental revolution
The mental revolution means a change of attitude on both sides of the factory.
- It stands for harmony and cooperation.
- Workers stop restricting output.
- Managers share the gains instead of fighting over them.
- Both sides turn to making the surplus bigger.
Taylor said the old quarrel was about how to divide the surplus. In his view it is better to increase the surplus so that both sides gain. This needs a change of mind in managers and workers, which he called a mental revolution.
Test yourself: What does Taylor's mental revolution stand for?
- Restricted output
- Harmony and cooperation
- Conflict and bargaining
- Economy and restricted output
Answer: B. It replaces conflict with harmony and restricted output with cooperation.
Functional foremanship
Taylor replaced the single foreman with eight specialists. They work in two groups.
- Planning group (office): route clerk, instruction card clerk, time and cost clerk, disciplinarian.
- Execution group (shop floor): gang boss, speed boss, repair boss, inspector.
- On the shop floor: speed boss, repair boss and inspection foreman.
- Route clerk and time clerk are office staff.
Taylor felt that one foreman could not master every skill. So he divided the foreman's work among specialists. Each worker would then have eight bosses, which is the price of specialisation and a common criticism.
| Group | Foremen |
|---|---|
| Planning (office) | Route clerk, instruction card clerk, time and cost clerk, disciplinarian |
| Execution (shop floor) | Gang boss, speed boss, repair boss, inspector |
Test yourself: Which of these serves the shop floor in functional foremanship?
- Route clerk
- Time clerk
- Speed boss
- Instruction clerk
Answer: C. The speed boss belongs to the execution group.
Goal and features of scientific management
The goal of scientific management is higher industrial efficiency. Taylor's features are shop-floor tools.
- Goal: higher industrial efficiency, not welfare or employment.
- Functional foremanship: specialist foremen, one per function.
- Separation of planning and execution.
- Differential piece-rate plan.
Taylor's works are A Piece-Rate System (1895), Shop Management (1903) and On the Art of Cutting Metals (1906). His Principles of Scientific Management came in 1911. The idea of one administrative science for every organisation belongs to the administrative management school, not to Taylor. Constructive conflict is Follett's idea.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Goal | Higher industrial efficiency |
| Foremanship | Functional |
| Planning and doing | Separated |
| Pay | Differential piece-rate |
Test yourself: What is the goal of scientific management?
- Higher industrial efficiency
- Employment
- Social welfare
- Worker welfare only
Answer: A. Taylor sought more output per worker.
Principles of organisation
Fayol's general theory
Henri Fayol, a French mining engineer, wrote about general management at the top of an organisation.
- Book: General and Industrial Management, 1916.
- Applies at the top management level. Taylor's work is at the workshop level.
- Five functions: planning, organising, commanding, coordinating, controlling.
- Fourteen principles, such as division of work, authority, unity of command and scalar chain.
- Founder of the management process school.
Fayol said there is nothing rigid or absolute in management affairs. Principles must bend to changing circumstances. He is called the father of administrative management, not the father of human relations.
| Thinker | Level | Contribution |
|---|---|---|
| Taylor | Workshop | Scientific management |
| Fayol | Top management | Fourteen principles |
| Mayo | Work groups | Human relations |
Test yourself: At which level does Fayol's general theory apply?
- Workshop level
- Top management level
- Middle management level
- Clerical level
Answer: B. Fayol dealt with general management at the top.
Gulick, POSDCORB and the four Ps
Luther Gulick gave the famous acronym POSDCORB in 1937, in a book he edited with Lyndall Urwick. He also gave four bases of departments.
- POSDCORB: planning, organising, staffing, directing, coordinating, reporting, budgeting.
- Source: Papers on the Science of Administration, 1937.
- Four Ps of departmentalisation: purpose, process, persons, place.
- Gulick's notes on the theory of organisation appeared in the same book.
POSDCORB lists the seven jobs of the chief executive. The four Ps tell how to group work in departments. Education or health is a purpose. Engineering is a process. Veterans are persons. A regional office is a place.
| P | Basis of grouping |
|---|---|
| Purpose | The goal served, such as education |
| Process | Skill or technique, such as law |
| Persons | People served, such as veterans |
| Place | Area covered, such as a region |
Test yourself: Who coined the acronym POSDCORB?
- Henri Fayol
- Gulick and Urwick
- Frederick Taylor
- Mary Parker Follett
Answer: B. Gulick coined it in the 1937 Papers on the Science of Administration, edited by Gulick and Urwick.
Urwick's eight principles
Lyndall Urwick listed eight principles of organisation. Questions ask which item is not in the list.
- Objective.
- Correspondence.
- Responsibility.
- Scalar principle.
- Span of control, specialisation, coordination and definition.
Urwick wrote The Elements of Administration in 1943. Specialisation is on his list. Generalisation is not. Remember the eight as Objective, Correspondence, Responsibility, Scalar, Span, Specialisation, Co-ordination and Definition.
Test yourself: Which is NOT among Urwick's eight principles?
- Correspondence
- Span of control
- Coordination
- Generalization
Answer: D. Specialisation is on the list, generalisation is not.
Follett on coordination
Mary Parker Follett gave four principles of coordination. She preferred direct contact to indirect control.
- Coordination by direct contact of the people concerned.
- Coordination in the early stages.
- Coordination as the reciprocal relation of all factors in a situation.
- Coordination as a continuing process.
Follett thought coordination works best when the people who are involved talk early and keep talking. A separate chief watching from above comes late and controls indirectly. She said the right order is the law of the situation, not the boss's order.
Test yourself: Which is NOT one of Follett's principles of coordination?
- Coordination in early stages
- Coordination as a continuing process
- Coordination by indirect control
- Coordination by direct contact
Answer: C. Follett stressed direct contact, not indirect control.
Classical theory and its critics
Classical theory sees a formal structure of authority built on universal principles. Simon called the principles proverbs.
- Gulick held that administration is governed by principles, like physics.
- Classical names: Taylor, Fayol, Gulick, Urwick, Weber, Willoughby.
- It treats people as parts of a machine, so it is called machine theory.
- Simon attacked the principles as homely proverbs, myths and slogans.
Simon's essay The Proverbs of Administration (1946) said the principles come in contradictory pairs. The human relations school grew as a reaction. Simon wanted a science built on decision-making and facts.
| Person | View |
|---|---|
| Gulick | Principles exist |
| Urwick | Principles exist |
| Simon | Principles are proverbs |
| Mayo | Human relations reaction |
Test yourself: Who called the classical principles homely proverbs and myths?
- Gulick
- Fayol
- Willoughby
- Simon
Answer: D. Simon's 1946 essay made the point.
Fayol's order, gangplank and delegation
Fayol listed planning, organising, command, coordination and control. His gangplank lets same-level officers talk directly.
- Order: planning, organising, command, coordination, control.
- It comes from General and Industrial Management (1916).
- Gangplank: level jumping across the hierarchy, with superiors told afterwards.
- Follett treated delegation as largely a myth. Terry wrote on Delegation.
The gangplank saves time and keeps the chain of command intact. Gulick's Bases of Organisation (1937) deals with departmental bases. Barnard wrote The Functions of the Executive and Fayol the principles of management.
| Author | Work or idea |
|---|---|
| Barnard | The Functions of the Executive |
| Fayol | Principles of management |
| Gulick | Bases of Organisation |
| Terry | Delegation |
Test yourself: What does Fayol's gangplank mean?
- A training tool
- Level jumping in the hierarchy
- Budget software
- An audit body
Answer: B. Same-level officers deal directly and inform superiors.
Span of control and its factors
Span of control is the number of subordinates one supervisor can direct well. There is no ideal number.
- Factors: age of the organisation, supervisor's personality, calibre of staff, structure.
- Others: function, time, space and delegation of authority.
- V. A. Graicunas (1933) showed how relations multiply.
- Hierarchy means through proper channel. Unity of command means one boss.
A settled organisation, skilled staff and simple repeated work allow a wide span. Later writers rejected a fixed figure. In a match, delegation is the flow of authority and span goes with supervision.
| Principle | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Span of control | Supervision |
| Hierarchy | Through proper channel |
| Delegation | Flow of authority |
| Unity of command | One single boss |
Test yourself: Which pair is correct?
- Span of control with supervision
- Hierarchy with one boss
- Delegation with proper channel
- Unity of command with supervision
Answer: A. Span of control is about how many a supervisor oversees.
🤝 Human relations and motivation
The Hawthorne studies, the main motivation theories, and the later management thinkers: Follett, Likert, Drucker and the leadership definitions.
Hawthorne and human relations
Mayo's Hawthorne experiments
Elton Mayo and colleagues ran the Hawthorne studies at Western Electric. They found that people matter more than machines.
- Illumination experiment: 1924-27.
- Relay Assembly Test Room: 1927-32.
- Mass Interview Programme: 1928-30.
- Bank Wiring Observation Room: 1931-32.
- Mayo's book: The Human Problems of an Industrial Civilization, 1933.
The lighting study did not show a link between light and output. So the team looked at the workers themselves. Group norms, attention and morale turned out to shape output. This started the human relations school.
| Experiment | Period |
|---|---|
| Illumination | 1924-27 |
| Relay Assembly Test Room | 1927-32 |
| Mass Interview Programme | 1928-30 |
| Bank Wiring Observation Room | 1931-32 |
Test yourself: Which experiment came first?
- Bank Wiring
- Mass Interview
- Relay Assembly
- Illumination
Answer: D. The lighting study began in 1924.
Informal groups and their labels
The Bank Wiring study showed informal group norms. Workers were given labels for conduct.
- Rate buster: does too much work.
- Chiseler: does too little work.
- Squealer: complains about a colleague to the supervisor.
- Inspector: keeps social distance or acts officially.
The group had an unwritten rule not to produce too much or too little. A rate buster broke it upwards. A chiseler broke it downwards. A squealer broke the code of silence. The labels are the group's own way of enforcing the norm.
| Label | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Rate buster | Does too much work |
| Chiseler | Does too little work |
| Squealer | Complains to the supervisor |
| Inspector | Keeps social distance |
Test yourself: Who is a squealer in the Bank Wiring study?
- One who does too much work
- One who complains to the supervisor
- One who does too little
- One who keeps distance
Answer: B. A squealer tells the supervisor about colleagues.
Human relations theory and its critics
Human relations theory treats the organisation as a social system. Critics attacked it as management manipulation.
- The organisation is a social system.
- Workers are human beings with feelings and needs.
- Informal elements matter a great deal for output.
- Critics said it ignored pay, conflict and union power.
- The United Auto Workers union in the USA called the researchers cow sociologists.
The theory arose against the machine view of the classical school. It says informal friendships and group pride raise output. Its critics said that happy workers were a tool for managers. They also said that it ignored conflict between owners and workers.
Test yourself: Which is incorrect about human relations theory?
- The organisation is a social system
- Workers are human beings
- Informal elements are unimportant for output
- Organisation has social ethics
Answer: C. Informal elements play an important role.
Motivation theories
Maslow's hierarchy of needs
Abraham Maslow arranged human needs in five levels. A lower level must be met before the next one drives behaviour.
- Physiological: food, water, shelter.
- Safety or security.
- Belonging or social needs.
- Esteem: status and recognition.
- Self-actualisation: reaching one's potential.
Maslow set out the idea in A Theory of Human Motivation, 1943. A hungry person worries about food, not status. Once a need is mostly met it stops motivating, and the next one takes over. Entertainment and spiritual needs are not levels in his scheme.
| Level | Need |
|---|---|
| 1 | Physiological |
| 2 | Safety |
| 3 | Belonging |
| 4 | Esteem |
| 5 | Self-actualisation |
Test yourself: What is the correct order from the base of Maslow's pyramid?
- Safety, physiological, esteem, belonging, self-actualisation
- Physiological, safety, belonging, esteem, self-actualisation
- Physiological, belonging, safety, esteem, self-actualisation
- Physiological, safety, esteem, belonging, self-actualisation
Answer: B. Belonging comes before esteem.
Herzberg's two factors
Frederick Herzberg split job factors into motivators and hygiene factors. Only motivators create real satisfaction.
- Motivators: achievement, recognition, the work itself, responsibility, advancement.
- Hygiene factors: salary, working conditions, policy, supervision.
- Hygiene factors prevent dissatisfaction but do not motivate.
- Book: The Motivation to Work, 1959.
Herzberg interviewed engineers and accountants about good and bad job experiences. Good experiences came from the job itself. Bad ones came from the setting. So a better office or salary only removes complaints. It does not inspire effort.
| Group | Examples |
|---|---|
| Motivators | Achievement, recognition, work itself |
| Hygiene | Salary, working conditions |
| Book | The Motivation to Work (1959) |
Test yourself: Which is a motivator in Herzberg's theory?
- Salary
- Working conditions
- Recognition
- Job security
Answer: C. Recognition is intrinsic to the job. The other options are hygiene items.
McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y
Douglas McGregor described two sets of assumptions about workers. His book is The Human Side of Enterprise.
- Theory X: people dislike work and need direction and control.
- Theory X: people avoid responsibility and want security.
- Theory Y: people can learn to seek responsibility.
- Theory Y: key process is integration of the individual and the enterprise.
- Scanlon Plan is also linked to him.
Under Theory X managers use close supervision and threats. Under Theory Y managers create conditions where members reach their own goals by helping the enterprise. The statement that best management is a true science is Taylor's belief, not McGregor's.
| Theory | View of workers |
|---|---|
| X | Dislike work, need control |
| Y | Self-directed, seek responsibility |
| Key process in Y | Integration |
Test yourself: Which assumption belongs to Theory X?
- People seek responsibility
- People need integration
- People dislike work and avoid it if they can
- People are self-controlled
Answer: C. Theory X sees an innate dislike of work.
Four theories of motivation matched
A common match item pairs four content theories with their authors.
- Two-factor theory: Herzberg.
- Hierarchy of needs: Maslow.
- Theory of needs: McClelland.
- Theory X and Y: McGregor.
- McClelland's needs: achievement, power, affiliation.
McClelland said that people differ in how strongly they want achievement, power and affiliation. Match the label to the thinker, not to the sound of the name. Hierarchy sounds like a managerial rank, but it is Maslow's.
| Theory | Thinker |
|---|---|
| Two-factor | Herzberg |
| Hierarchy of needs | Maslow |
| Theory of needs | McClelland |
| Theory X and Y | McGregor |
Test yourself: Who gave the theory of needs: achievement, power and affiliation?
- Maslow
- Herzberg
- McClelland
- McGregor
Answer: C. McClelland named those three needs.
Later management thinkers
Likert's four systems and linking pin
Rensis Likert described four systems of management. He also gave the linking pin model.
- System 1: exploitative authoritative.
- System 2: benevolent authoritative.
- System 3: consultative.
- System 4: participative, the most efficient.
- Books: New Patterns of Management (1961), The Human Organization (1967).
The four systems run from rigid top-down control to full group participation. In the linking pin model each manager belongs to the group he leads and to the group above him. This joins the levels like a pin joins two plates. Maturity-immaturity is not one of the systems.
| System | Style |
|---|---|
| 1 | Exploitative authoritative |
| 2 | Benevolent authoritative |
| 3 | Consultative |
| 4 | Participative |
Test yourself: Who gave the linking pin model?
- Elton Mayo
- Rensis Likert
- Fred Riggs
- Woodrow Wilson
Answer: B. Likert described managers as pins joining overlapping groups.
Mary Parker Follett
Mary Parker Follett was a prophet of management. She stressed the human and the group side of organisation.
- Constructive conflict: conflict can be useful.
- Three ways to handle it: domination, compromise, integration.
- Integration is the constructive way. Both sides get what they want.
- Law of the situation: orders come from facts, not from a person.
- Power with, not power over.
Follett wrote Creative Experience in 1924. She said that conflict is natural. Domination leaves one side angry. Compromise leaves both with less. Integration finds a new answer that satisfies both. Her ideas on coordination appear in the principles branch.
| Way to handle conflict | Result |
|---|---|
| Domination | One side wins |
| Compromise | Both give up something |
| Integration | Both needs are met |
Test yourself: Who gave the idea of constructive conflict?
- Mary Parker Follett
- Woodrow Wilson
- Max Weber
- Henri Fayol
Answer: A. Follett argued that conflict can be made creative.
Peter Drucker and management by objectives
Peter Drucker is called the father of modern management. He introduced management by objectives.
- Management by objectives: The Practice of Management, 1954.
- Knowledge worker: his term.
- The Effective Executive, 1967.
- Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices, 1973.
- Management Challenges for the 21st Century, 1999.
In management by objectives, manager and subordinate agree on targets. Performance is measured against them. Drucker also listed sins of non-performance: dogmatism, lofty objectives and attempting too many things at once. He saw management as a discipline, not as a machine.
| Work | Year |
|---|---|
| The Practice of Management | 1954 |
| The Effective Executive | 1967 |
| Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices | 1973 |
| Management Challenges for the 21st Century | 1999 |
Test yourself: In which book did Drucker put forward management by objectives?
- Managing for Results
- The New Society
- The Frontier of Management
- The Practice of Management
Answer: D. It appeared in The Practice of Management in 1954.
Leadership definitions
Writers define leadership differently. Questions give the line and ask for the author.
- Koontz and O'Donnell: ability to induce subordinates to work with zeal and confidence.
- G. R. Terry: activity of influencing people to strive willingly for mutual objectives.
- Keith Davis: ability to persuade others to seek defined objectives with enthusiasm.
- Follett: power with, not power over.
Match key words. Zeal and confidence belongs to Koontz and O'Donnell. Willingly and mutual objectives belongs to Terry. Do not mix these with Barnard's functions of the executive.
| Author | Key words |
|---|---|
| Koontz and O'Donnell | Zeal and confidence |
| G. R. Terry | Willingly, mutual objectives |
| Keith Davis | Persuade, enthusiastically |
Test yourself: Who defined leadership as influencing people to strive willingly for mutual objectives?
- James Rost
- Keith Davis
- M. P. Follett
- G. R. Terry
Answer: D. Terry's wording uses willingly and mutual objectives.
Management theories matched with ideas
Match lists often tie a theory to its core idea. Learn one line for each.
- Scientific management: a true science of work benefiting workers and managers.
- New public management: keep improving programmes and services.
- Human relations: organisation as a social system.
- Rational decision-making: intelligence, design and choice.
- Four distinctions are listed in the table below.
The decision phases of intelligence, design and choice are Simon's. The principles-versus-mechanics line comes from Taylor's mental revolution. The charismatic-legal-rational split is Weber's. These one-liners solve most match items.
| Concept | Thinker |
|---|---|
| Obedience versus acceptance | Barnard |
| Economic versus administrative man | Simon |
| Charismatic versus legal-rational | Weber |
| Principles versus mechanics | Taylor |
Test yourself: Who distinguished economic man from administrative man?
- Chester Barnard
- H. Simon
- F. W. Taylor
- Max Weber
Answer: B. Simon argued that real managers satisfice.
Thinkers matched with schools and works
Many matches pair a thinker with a school, a book or an idea. The firm pairs settle them.
- Mayo: human relations. Fayol: classical. Taylor: scientific management.
- Taylor: mental revolution. Drucker: management by objectives.
- Maslow: A Theory of Human Motivation (1943). Simon: Administrative Behavior (1947).
- Riggs: Ecology of Public Administration. Dror: Public Policy Making Re-examined.
Drucker's Practice of Management came in 1954. Argyris wrote On Organizational Learning. Marx wrote the Eighteenth Brumaire. Herzberg is famous for the two-factor motivation theory. S. Jaishankar wrote The India Way, a foreign policy book. Follett first urged workers' participation in management.
| Thinker | Idea or work |
|---|---|
| Taylor | Mental revolution |
| Drucker | Management by objectives |
| Maslow | Hierarchy of needs |
| Herzberg | Two-factor theory |
| Dror | Public policy making |
Test yourself: Who gave management by objectives?
- Taylor
- Barnard
- Drucker
- Maslow
Answer: C. Peter Drucker in The Practice of Management.
🧩 Organisation theory, Barnard and Simon
How organisations communicate and decide, Simon's satisficing, systems thinking, and Chester Barnard's theory of the formal organisation.
Communication and decisions
The communication process
Communication runs through fixed steps. The first four steps are asked in order.
- Sender has an idea.
- Encoding turns the idea into symbols.
- Message is the encoded content.
- Channel carries the message.
- Then receiver, decoding and feedback.
The full chain is sender, encoding, message, channel, receiver, decoding, feedback. The sender must encode before there is a message. The channel such as speech or email then carries it. The receiver decodes it and gives feedback.
| Step | Role |
|---|---|
| Sender | Has the idea |
| Encoding | Turns idea into symbols |
| Channel | Carries the message |
| Decoding | Receiver's reading |
Test yourself: Which is the correct first four steps?
- Sender, encoding, message, channel
- Sender, message, receiver, encoding
- Message, channel, feedback, encoding
- Sender, encoding, decoding, receiver
Answer: A. The first four are sender, encoding, message and channel.
Decision-making steps
A rational decision follows an order of steps. Information search comes before listing alternatives.
- Problem recognition.
- Search for information.
- Definition of alternatives.
- Selection of the best alternative.
- Implementation and evaluation come after.
Simon described the decision phases as intelligence, design and choice. Intelligence means finding the problem and the facts. Design means building alternatives. Choice means picking one. The step list in the exam maps onto these three.
| Thinker | Decision idea |
|---|---|
| Simon | Programmed and non-programmed |
| Drucker | Generic and unique |
| Barnard | Organisational and personal |
| Follett | Constructive conflict |
Test yourself: Which is the correct order of decision-making steps?
- Search, recognise, select, define
- Recognise, search, define alternatives, select
- Select, define, search, recognise
- Define, select, recognise, search
Answer: B. A problem is recognised first and the choice comes last.
Simon, satisficing and bounded rationality
Herbert Simon said managers do not maximise. They choose a path that is good enough.
- Satisficing: a choice that meets needs at an acceptable level.
- Rationality is bounded by limited time and information.
- Book: Administrative Behavior, 1947.
- He won the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1978.
The economic man of old theory knows everything and picks the best. Simon's administrative man knows little and settles for a satisfactory option. The line that we want a choice mechanism leading to a satisficing path is his.
Test yourself: Who spoke of a satisficing path?
- Herbert Simon
- Chester Barnard
- Max Weber
- Mary Parker Follett
Answer: A. Satisficing is Simon's key concept.
Systems theory of organisation
Systems theory sees the organisation as a cooperative system of interdependent parts.
- The organisation is a whole of related parts.
- Individuals cooperate to reach goals they cannot reach alone.
- It is an open system that deals with its environment.
- Chester Barnard is the standard reference.
People, tasks and structure depend on each other. A change in one part shows in the others. Barnard's The Functions of the Executive, 1938, treats the organisation as a cooperative system. Easton used systems ideas in politics.
Test yourself: Systems theory studies the organisation as a
- Continuous system
- Cooperative system
- Disorganised system
- Constrained mechanism
Answer: B. It stresses interdependence and cooperation.
Direction of internal communication
Internal communication moves upward, downward and across. Informal talk moves in all directions.
- Downward: orders, instructions, policies.
- Upward: reports, feedback, suggestions.
- Horizontal: coordination between staff at one level.
- Bounded rationality is Herbert Simon's model from 1947.
Formal communication follows the chain of command, which is slow for two same-level sections. The grapevine is the informal form. Simon said people satisfice and decide within limits of information and time. Barnard's The Functions of the Executive (1938) deals with the executive.
| Direction | Content |
|---|---|
| Downward | Orders and policies |
| Upward | Reports and feedback |
| Horizontal | Coordination |
| Informal | Grapevine |
Test yourself: Which direction can internal communication take?
- Upward only
- Downward only
- Upward and downward only
- Upward, downward and across
Answer: D. All three directions are used.
Chester Barnard
Barnard on formal organisation
Chester Barnard defined organisation as a system of consciously coordinated activities of two or more persons.
- Book: The Functions of the Executive, 1938.
- Three elements: communication, willingness to contribute action, common purpose.
- Formal organisation arises when persons are willing to contribute action.
- Money is a weak motive. Non-material incentives matter.
- He is the spiritual father of the social system school.
Barnard said an organisation survives only if it is effective and efficient. Effective means it reaches its goal. Efficient means it satisfies the motives of its members. Persons contribute to the organisation when the inducements they receive match what they give.
| Element | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Communication | Persons can talk to each other |
| Willingness | Persons contribute action |
| Common purpose | A shared goal |
Test yourself: According to Barnard, a formal organisation arises when
- Persons have different goals
- Persons will contribute action
- Only informal channels exist
- Executive avoids incentives
Answer: B. Willingness to contribute action, with communication and purpose, forms it.
Acceptance theory and zone of indifference
Barnard said authority flows from the acceptance of orders by subordinates, not from the top alone.
- Acceptance theory of authority.
- Zone of indifference: orders accepted without question.
- Contribution-satisfaction equilibrium.
- Distinction between obedience and acceptance.
- Decisions can be organisational or personal.
A subordinate accepts an order if understood, consistent with purpose, in his interest and possible to carry out. Orders inside the zone are obeyed without thought. Barnard named an order as authoritative only when it is accepted.
| Idea | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Acceptance theory | Authority rests on acceptance |
| Zone of indifference | Orders obeyed without question |
| Equilibrium | Inducements balance contributions |
Test yourself: Which idea is NOT Chester Barnard's?
- Zone of indifference
- Contribution-satisfaction equilibrium
- Functions of the executive
- Bounded rationality
Answer: D. Bounded rationality belongs to Simon.
Informal communication in Barnard
Barnard said informal channels carry what formal channels cannot.
- They carry intangible facts, opinions, suggestions and suspicions.
- They help cohesion and speed the passing of information.
- They protect the formal system.
- Communication is the means to a common purpose.
A formal system has files and orders. People also need to share rumours and opinions that cannot be written down. Barnard says the informal organisation makes the formal one work better. It is not a rival.
Test yourself: Who said that intangible facts and suspicions pass through informal channels?
- Chester Barnard
- Max Weber
- Herbert Simon
- Chris Argyris
Answer: A. Barnard wrote about informal communication in 1938.
🗂️ Bureaucracy and personnel
Weber's types of authority and ideal bureaucracy, Merton's criticism, and the rules of personnel administration in India.
Weber and bureaucracy
Weber's three types of authority
Max Weber described three kinds of legitimate authority. Each rests on a different belief.
- Traditional: custom and inherited status, such as kings and chiefs.
- Charismatic: extraordinary personal qualities, such as a prophet or hero.
- Legal-rational: rules and offices, the basis of modern bureaucracy.
- The correct phrase is legal-rational, not legal-irrational.
People obey a traditional ruler because it has always been so. They obey a charismatic leader because they trust the person. They obey a legal-rational officer because the rules give the office its power.
| Type | Basis |
|---|---|
| Traditional | Inherited status and custom |
| Charismatic | Exceptional personal qualities |
| Legal-rational | Rules and office |
Test yourself: What does traditional authority involve?
- Rules and regulations
- Magical personal qualities
- Authority from inherited status
- Technical skill only
Answer: C. Traditional authority rests on inherited status and custom.
The ideal type and its drawbacks
Weber's bureaucracy is an ideal type built on rules, hierarchy and impersonality. Critics find gaps in it.
- Hierarchy of offices.
- Written rules and files.
- Specialisation and division of work.
- Impersonality and a career based on merit.
- Drawback: it lacks normative factors that guide action.
The model shows how a machine-like office is meant to run. It does not tell what values should guide the officials. It is also silent on human feelings and informal relations. This makes it efficient but cold.
Test yourself: Which is a drawback of the bureaucratic model?
- Lack of legal-rational principles
- Lack of normative factors guiding action
- Lack of written rules
- Lack of hierarchy
Answer: B. It is silent on norms and values.
Merton and the dysfunctions
Robert Merton showed that bureaucratic rules can backfire. His 1957 work says bureaucrats resist change.
- Displacement of goals: rules become ends in themselves.
- Trained incapacity: training makes officials rigid.
- Depersonalisation of relationships.
- Source: Bureaucratic Structure and Personality.
Rules begin as means to reach goals. Over time officials follow them for their own sake. The skills that served the office yesterday make it hard to adjust today. Merton called this trained incapacity. Impersonal rules also cut human warmth.
| Dysfunction | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Displacement of goals | Rules become ends |
| Trained incapacity | Training makes officials rigid |
| Depersonalisation | Impersonal rules cut relationships |
Test yourself: Who argued that bureaucrats resist change in 1957?
- Anthony Downs
- Judith Gruber
- D. Thompson
- Robert K. Merton
Answer: D. Merton's essay on trained incapacity gave the view.
Critics and types of bureaucracy
Several writers criticised bureaucracy, each in a famous phrase. Colonial bureaucracy was a ruling bureaucracy.
- Thomas Carlyle: the continental nuisance (1850).
- Karl Marx: bureaucracy as an exploitative class instrument.
- Warren Bennis: bureaucracy would go out of use in his Beyond Bureaucracy.
- Herbert Morrison: bureaucracy is the price of parliamentary democracy.
Weber saw bureaucracy as technically the most efficient form. Crozier studied the vicious circle of rigidity. Peter Blau wrote on the dynamics of bureaucracy. The colonial service, the steel frame, was the instrument of foreign rule and not of an elected government.
| Writer | View |
|---|---|
| Carlyle | Continental nuisance |
| Marx | Exploitative class instrument |
| Bennis | Going out of use |
| Morrison | Price of parliamentary democracy |
Test yourself: Who called bureaucracy the continental nuisance?
- Thomas Carlyle
- Max Weber
- Karl Marx
- Michel Crozier
Answer: A. Carlyle used the phrase in Latter-Day Pamphlets.
Max Weber's works
Weber's books
Questions ask which titles are Max Weber's. A few are not his.
- The Theory of Social and Economic Organization.
- Economy and Society, his major posthumous work.
- Roman Agrarian History and its Significance for Public and Private Law, 1891.
- The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, 1904-05.
Roman Agrarian History was Weber's habilitation thesis, a post-doctoral qualification for teaching in Germany. The Theory of Social and Economic Organization is the English translation of part of his writing. Titles like The Elements of Administration are Urwick's.
| Book | Author |
|---|---|
| Economy and Society | Weber |
| Roman Agrarian History | Weber |
| The Elements of Administration | Urwick |
| The Functions of the Executive | Barnard |
Test yourself: Who wrote Roman Agrarian History and its Significance for Public and Private Law?
- Jawaharlal Nehru
- Max Weber
- Adam Smith
- Woodrow Wilson
Answer: B. It was Weber's 1891 thesis.
Weber's iron cage and Sociology of Religion
Weber warned of an iron cage of rules. His Sociology of Religion is part of Economy and Society.
- Iron cage: rule-based rational control traps people.
- Bureaucracy is a key part of rational-legal authority.
- It means domination through knowledge, with merit appointments.
- Works: Protestant Ethic (1905), Sociology of Religion, Politics as a Vocation.
Weber's three types of authority are traditional, charismatic and legal-rational. Bureaucracy belongs to the last. A statement that bureaucracy enjoys popular acceptability in a democracy does not fit his theory.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Iron cage | Protestant Ethic, 1905 |
| Authority type | Legal-rational |
| Bureaucracy means | Domination through knowledge |
| Religion book | The Sociology of Religion |
Test yourself: Who wrote The Sociology of Religion?
- Max Weber
- John Locke
- Herbert Marcuse
- Fayol
Answer: A. Weber wrote it.
Personnel administration
Spoils and removal of officials
The spoils system gives public jobs to the winning party. Reformers wanted jobs by merit.
- Spoils system: jobs go to supporters of the winner.
- Merit system: jobs go by examination and ability.
- Jefferson's stated policy: no removal for political opinion alone.
- Misconduct is a just ground for removal.
In the item, the assertion about Jefferson and the reason about misconduct are both correct. But the reason does not explain the assertion. The reason tells when removal is fair. The assertion tells what Jefferson refused to do.
Test yourself: In the Jefferson item, how are A and R related?
- R explains A
- R is true but does not explain A
- A is false
- R is false
Answer: B. Both are true, but R does not explain A.
Discipline and control in India
In India, civil servants are disciplined under service rules. Some methods are rarely used.
- Minor penalties: censure, withholding of increments or promotion.
- Major penalties: reduction in rank, compulsory retirement, removal, dismissal.
- Rules: Classification, Control and Appeal rules.
- Cash fines are rarely used.
A question asked for a negative method of control that is least used in India. The answer was imposition of cash fines. Written warnings, reprimand and reduction in rank after an inquiry are in common use.
Test yourself: Which negative method is least used in India?
- Written warnings
- Cash fines
- Reduction in rank after inquiry
- Administrative reprimand
Answer: B. Fines are rarely imposed on government employees.
All India Services
India has three All India Services under Article 312. They serve both the Centre and the states.
- Indian Administrative Service.
- Indian Police Service.
- Indian Forest Service.
- Indian Foreign Service and customs are Central Services.
Parliament can create an All India Service if the Rajya Sabha passes a resolution by two-thirds. These officers are recruited by the Centre and posted to states. The Foreign Service serves only the Union.
| Service | Type |
|---|---|
| IAS | All India |
| IPS | All India |
| Indian Forest Service | All India |
| Indian Foreign Service | Central |
Test yourself: Which does NOT come under All India Services?
- IAS
- IPS
- Indian Foreign Service
- Indian Forest Service
Answer: C. The Foreign Service is a Central Service.
Civil service committees in order
Four Indian committees on civil service recruitment and reform came in a fixed order.
- Kothari Committee: 1974-76, recruitment policy.
- Satish Chandra Committee: 1988-89, examination review.
- Alagh Committee: 2000-01, examination reform.
- Hota Committee: 2003-04, civil service reform.
Kothari proposed the three stage pattern of preliminary, main and interview. The Satish Chandra Committee reviewed the examination and led to the 1993 pattern. Alagh and Hota reviewed it again.
| Committee | Years |
|---|---|
| Kothari | 1974-76 |
| Satish Chandra | 1988-89 |
| Alagh | 2000-01 |
| Hota | 2003-04 |
Test yourself: Which committee came last?
- Kothari
- Satish Chandra
- Alagh
- Hota
Answer: D. The Hota Committee reported in 2003-04.
Fulton, JCM, open systems and recruitment
The Fulton Committee asked for a unified grading structure in Britain. The US has an open service.
- Fulton Committee 1966-68: unified grading structure, specialists, Civil Service College.
- Joint Consultative Machinery: Second Pay Commission advice, set up 1966.
- USA: entry at almost any level and age.
- Glenn Stahl: sound recruitment is the cornerstone of personnel structure.
JCM has a National Council, Departmental Councils and Office Councils. The UK, France and India follow closed career systems. The US merit system began with the Pendleton Act of 1883.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Fulton Committee | Unified grading, UK |
| JCM | Second Pay Commission |
| Open service | USA |
| Closed service | UK, France, India |
Test yourself: Which Pay Commission recommended the Joint Consultative Machinery?
- First
- Second
- Third
- Fourth
Answer: B. The Second Pay Commission proposed it.
🌍 Comparative, development and new management
Riggs and the study of administration across societies, development administration, and New Public Management.
Comparative administration
The field and its pioneers
Comparative public administration studies administrative systems across countries. Fred Riggs is called its father.
- Studies structure, process, behaviour, roles and impact at the international level.
- Riggs chaired the Comparative Administration Group through the 1960s.
- The group sat inside the American Society for Public Administration.
- Heady's concerns: search for theory, practical use, contribution to comparative politics, ongoing problems.
- Robert Dahl suggested cross-cultural studies.
Dahl's 1947 essay argued that administration cannot escape its setting. So any science of administration must be tested in many societies. In the assertion-reason item Dahl's call is correct, but the reason is false. Heady listed all four concerns.
| Name | Contribution |
|---|---|
| Fred Riggs | Father of the field, CAG chairman |
| Ferrel Heady | Four concerns of comparative study |
| Robert Dahl | Cross-cultural studies |
| Gerald Caiden | The Dynamics of Public Administration |
Test yourself: Who is called the father of comparative public administration?
- Edward Weidner
- Fred Riggs
- Ferrel Heady
- Chester Barnard
Answer: B. Riggs led the Comparative Administration Group.
Riggs's three models
Fred Riggs set out three ideal types of society. They run like light through a prism.
- Fused: undifferentiated structures, as in agraria.
- Prismatic: mixed and in transition.
- Diffracted: functionally specific, as in industria.
- Books: The Ecology of Public Administration (1961), Administration in Developing Countries (1964).
In a fused society one structure does many jobs. In a diffracted one each structure does one job. A prism splits white light into colours, so the prismatic society sits between the two. The fused model fits a farm-based society, rule by a king and a barter economy.
| Model | Society type |
|---|---|
| Fused | Agraria, traditional |
| Prismatic | Transitional |
| Diffracted | Industria, modern |
Test yourself: Which are Riggs's models?
- Fused, focussed, prismatic
- Fused, prismatic, diffracted
- Rainbow, prismatic, diffracted
- Fused, rainbow, diffracted
Answer: B. The three are fused, prismatic and diffracted.
Features of the prismatic society
The prismatic society mixes old and new. Riggs gave it several named traits.
- Heterogeneity: old and new exist side by side.
- Formalism: gap between formal rules and practice.
- Overlapping: old functions continue beside new structures.
- Poly-functionalism: one structure does many functions.
- The sala is the bureaucratic office of the prismatic model.
Because the old and the new stand side by side, change in a prismatic society is inconsistent and incomplete. That explains the assertion in the 2023 item. The sala is like a market-office, as the bazaar-canteen is a market-restaurant.
| Trait | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Heterogeneity | Old and new together |
| Formalism | Rules differ from practice |
| Overlapping | Old functions persist |
| Sala | The office of the prismatic model |
Test yourself: Which is a prismatic trait?
- Heterogeneity
- Pure universalism
- Single-function structures
- Absence of formalism
Answer: A. Old and new coexist in a prismatic society.
Ecology of administration
Ecology and Riggs
Ecology is the study of living things and their surroundings. Riggs applied the idea to administration.
- Ernst Haeckel coined the word ecology in 1866.
- It comes from the Greek oikos, meaning household.
- Riggs studied how social, economic, political and cultural settings shape administration.
- Book: The Ecology of Public Administration, 1961.
A plant grows according to soil and weather. In the same way an administrative system takes its shape from its setting. Riggs said we cannot understand an office without its society. In the list of match items, ecological approach goes with Riggs.
Test yourself: Who coined the term ecology in 1866?
- Fred Riggs
- Robert Dahl
- Ernst Haeckel
- Houghton Mifflin
Answer: C. Haeckel, a German biologist, coined it.
Development administration
Hallmarks of development administration
Development administration is the administration of change for national development. It is active, not passive.
- Change-oriented.
- Goal-oriented.
- Result-oriented.
- Client-oriented and participative.
- Not status-quo oriented.
The idea is linked to Edward Weidner and Fred Riggs. It grew in newly independent countries that needed to plan and build quickly. Status-quo orientation fits regulatory administration that keeps things as they are.
| Concept | Thinker or event |
|---|---|
| Decision making | Herbert Simon |
| Ecological approach | Fred Riggs |
| New Public Administration | Minnowbrook 1968 |
| Development administration | Edward Weidner |
Test yourself: Which is NOT a hallmark of development administration?
- Change-oriented
- Goal-oriented
- Status-quo oriented
- Result-oriented
Answer: C. Development administration is about change.
Components and Gant's book
Development administration needs new agencies, competent planning and trained staff. George Gant wrote its standard book.
- New management agencies and systems must be devised.
- Competent planning and monitoring of delivery.
- Trained personnel for specialised support.
- Book: Development Administration: Concepts, Goals, Methods, 1979, by George F. Gant.
Gant defined it as management of change toward progressive political, economic and social goals. Centralising work in few agencies and regulating commercial bodies are not its approach.
Test yourself: Who wrote Development Administration: Concepts, Goals, Methods?
- Sabu Thomas
- Fred Riggs
- George F. Gant
- Michel Crozier
Answer: C. It is Gant's 1979 book.
New Public Management
Themes of New Public Management
New Public Management brings business methods into government. It is result-driven and customer-focused.
- Adopt private sector practices.
- Improved reporting and monitoring.
- Performance targets.
- Steering rather than rowing.
- Decentralisation, competition and customer focus.
NPM wants government to buy services rather than run them. It moves away from the traditional public sector style. It is the reverse of raw bureaucratic power, concentration and internalisation.
| Feature | NPM view |
|---|---|
| Style | Result and objective focus |
| Role of government | Steering, not rowing |
| Structure | Decentralised, less bureaucratic |
| Practices | Private sector methods |
Test yourself: Which is NOT an attribute of NPM?
- Result orientation
- Managerial approach
- Separation of steering from rowing
- Raw bureaucratic power and concentration
Answer: D. NPM prefers decentralisation to concentration.
Reinventing Government and NPM authors
Osborne and Gaebler's 1992 book made NPM popular. Other scholars wrote the main NPM texts.
- Reinventing Government, 1992: David Osborne and Ted Gaebler.
- Hood: The Art of the State.
- Lane: New Public Management: An Introduction.
- Barzelay: The New Public Management: Improving Research and Policy Dialogue.
- Stephen Osborne: Public Management, critical perspectives.
Reinventing Government has ten principles, such as steering rather than rowing, mission-driven government and competition among providers. Match lists give the NPM authors with their titles.
| Author | Book |
|---|---|
| Osborne and Gaebler | Reinventing Government |
| Christopher Hood | The Art of the State |
| Jan-Erik Lane | New Public Management: An Introduction |
| Michael Barzelay | The NPM: Improving Research and Policy Dialogue |
Test yourself: Who wrote Reinventing Government in 1992?
- Robert Denhardt
- Pfiffner and Presthus
- Osborne and Gaebler
- Gordon Tullock
Answer: C. David Osborne and Ted Gaebler wrote it.
Dunleavy's components and NPM features
Dunleavy named three components of New Public Management. Contracting out is a typical feature.
- Dunleavy: disaggregation, competition, incentivisation.
- Features: contracting out, devolution, performance appraisal, focus on management.
- The Thatcher government in Britain began NPM in the 1980s.
- Christopher Hood named it in 1991.
Osborne and Gaebler's Reinventing Government (1992) said to steer, not row. Dunleavy and others argued in 2006 that NPM was dead, replaced by digital-era governance. A set of A's (agility, alertness, accountability, alignment, adaptability) was also asked for the new managerial approach.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Dunleavy | Disaggregation, competition, incentivisation |
| Hood | Named NPM, 1991 |
| Osborne and Gaebler | Reinventing Government |
| Feature | Contracting out |
Test yourself: Which are Dunleavy's three NPM components?
- Centralisation, power, authority
- Disaggregation, competition, incentivisation
- Rigidity, timidity, bureaucratisation
- Conflict, displacement, conservation
Answer: B. Those three themes describe NPM.
Practise Public Administration
All 170 past questions in this unit, with full explanations.
Practise this unit