Unit 2: Political Thought mind map
Unit 2 of UGC NET Political Science is Political Thought. It covers the great thinkers from Plato and Aristotle to Marx, Rawls, Arendt and Fanon. Questions mostly ask who said a line, which thinker wrote which book, in what order books or stages come, or which statements about a thinker are correct. This map teaches each thinker in plain words and puts the names, books and years into tables. Each concept gives crisp points, a simple explanation, an everyday example, a table to memorise and a short self-test. Everything comes from past UGC NET Political Science papers.
Short of time? Start with Hegel, Marx and Marxism. It carries the most questions (44). Use the List view tab for a fast read the night before the exam.
All the notes in one place
This is the same content as the map, written out so you can read it from top to bottom. Open a branch to read it.
🏺 Classical and Renaissance thought
Plato, Aristotle, Machiavelli and Confucius: the Greek, Roman and Chinese roots that the exam keeps returning to.
Plato
Theory of Forms and the allegory of the cave
Plato says the world we see is only a shadow. The real things are perfect Ideas.
- Ideas or Forms are perfect, eternal and fixed.
- The visible world is a changing, imperfect copy.
- The Idea of the Good is the highest Idea.
- The allegory of the cave is in The Republic, Book VII.
Prisoners in a cave see only shadows on a wall and think they are real. One prisoner is freed and sees the sun. He returns to teach the others, who resist him. The sun stands for the Idea of the Good. A chair rots, but the Idea of a chair does not.
| World | Nature |
|---|---|
| World of Ideas | Perfect, eternal, known by reason |
| World of appearances | Changing, imperfect, known by the senses |
| Idea of the Good | Highest Idea, like the sun |
Test yourself: Which one is perfect, eternal and fixed according to Plato?
- Matter
- Ideas
- Raw material
- Darkness
Answer: B. Ideas or Forms are unchanging. Things we see are only copies.
Soul, classes and philosopher-kings
Plato matches the three parts of the soul to the three classes of the state.
- Soul has reason, spirit and appetite.
- Rulers use reason and show wisdom.
- Soldiers use spirit and show courage.
- The state is the individual writ large.
Plato builds the state on the same three parts as the soul. Rulers are philosopher-kings. He says cities will never rest from evil until philosophers become kings. The Republic aims to picture a state perfected by justice and ruled by the Idea of the Good.
| Soul part | Class | Virtue |
|---|---|---|
| Reason | Rulers | Wisdom |
| Spirit | Soldiers | Courage |
| Appetite | Producers | Moderation |
Test yourself: What are the three parts of the soul in Plato?
- Reason, spirit, appetite
- Reason, spirit, aptitude
- Reason, will, desire
- Spirit, virtue, wisdom
Answer: A. Plato names reason, spirit and appetite. Aptitude is not one of them.
Ideal state and communism of the guardians
Plato asks his rulers to give up property and family so that greed cannot corrupt them.
- Communism applies only to guardians, not to producers.
- No private property and no private family for guardians.
- The aim is to remove objects of desire.
- Plato stresses duties more than rights.
A ruler with no land, house or family to enrich cannot be tempted by self-interest. So he rules for the good of all. Plato also admits women into the guardian class. He calls his ideal state a pattern laid up in heaven, an idea more than a working reality.
Test yourself: Who proposes an ascetic communism to remove objects of desire?
- Karl Marx
- Plato
- Glaucon
- Polybius
Answer: B. Plato proposed common living for the guardian class in The Republic.
The Apology
The Apology is Plato's record of the defence speech of Socrates at his trial.
- Trial took place in 399 BC.
- Characters are Socrates and his accusers.
- Meletus is the chief accuser.
- Charge: impiety and corrupting the youth.
The Greek word apologia means a legal defence. It does not mean saying sorry. Socrates cross-examines Meletus, defends his way of life and is condemned by the jury. Plato was his pupil and wrote down the events.
Test yourself: The characters of the Apology are Socrates and
- Crito
- Polemarchus
- His accusers
- Plato
Answer: C. The dialogue records his trial speech against Meletus and others.
Plato: order of works, dialectic and education
Plato's dialogues fall in three periods. The Republic also sets a scheme of education.
- Order: Apology, Republic, Statesman, Laws.
- Dialectic as a method first appears in Plato's writings, not Socrates'.
- Education: early years to six, a test at twenty, another at thirty.
- Dunning: the Republic starts a scientific attack on the idea of the good.
Apology is early, the Republic middle, and the Statesman and Laws late. Socrates used questions but wrote nothing, so the dialectic in writing is Plato's. In the Republic, education serves justice and turns the soul to truth.
Test yourself: Which is the correct order of Plato's texts?
- Apology, Republic, Statesman, Laws
- Republic, Apology, Laws, Statesman
- Laws, Republic, Statesman, Apology
- Apology, Laws, Republic, Statesman
Answer: A. Early, middle, then two late works.
Aristotle
The polis and the purpose of the state
Aristotle says man is a political animal. The state exists for the good life.
- Polis is natural and prior to the individual, in purpose not in time.
- Polis is the highest and most comprehensive association.
- Polis must be big enough for self-sufficiency and small enough for good rule.
- If life only were the aim, slaves and animals might form a state.
The household serves life and the village serves wider needs. The polis exists for the good life. That is why animals and slaves cannot form a state, since they have no share in happiness or free choice. The phrase polis is man writ large is Plato's analogy, not Aristotle's.
| Statement | Aristotle? |
|---|---|
| Large enough and small enough | Yes |
| Prior to the individual in purpose | Yes |
| Highest association | Yes |
| Polis is man writ large | No, this is Plato |
Test yourself: Who said that if life only were the object, slaves and brute animals might form a state?
- Plato
- Aristotle
- Confucius
- Hannah Arendt
Answer: B. Aristotle says the state aims at the good life, not mere life.
Slavery in the Politics
Aristotle defends slavery in Book I of the Politics through the idea of natural slaves.
- Some are marked out from birth for subjection, others for rule.
- A slave is a living tool of the master.
- Slaves have enough reason to obey but not to rule.
- Book I deals with the household.
Aristotle says nature fits some people to rule with their minds and others to be ruled. He argues slavery then benefits both. Later books turn to constitutions and revolutions. Today this view is rejected, but the exam asks it as a fact about his thought.
Test yourself: In which book of the Politics does Aristotle justify slavery?
- Book 1
- Book 4
- Book 6
- Book 7
Answer: A. He discusses the household and slavery at the start of the Politics.
Popular rule, Plato's second best and his works
Aristotle fears that the many can be led by a demagogue. His works are often asked.
- Democracy is a deviant form that easily decays.
- The poor resent the wealth of the few and follow a demagogue.
- Sabine called Aristotle's ideal state Plato's second best.
- Works: Politics, Nicomachean Ethics, Eudemian Ethics.
In the Politics the masses resent the rich. A persuasive leader flatters them and rules through the mob. Sabine, in A History of Political Theory, said Aristotle's best state is close to the second-best state of Plato's Laws. The Apology is not Aristotle's work.
| Item | Link |
|---|---|
| Politics | Aristotle, constitutions and best state |
| Nicomachean Ethics | Aristotle, traditionally named for his son |
| Eudemian Ethics | Aristotle, traditionally named for a student |
| Apology | Plato, not Aristotle |
Test yourself: Aristotle feared that the masses would too easily fall under the sway of
- The king
- The leading citizens
- The demagogue
- None of these
Answer: C. A popular leader inflames resentment and rules through the crowd.
Aristotle: citizen and the state before the individual
Aristotle defines a citizen by a share in office. The state comes first by nature.
- A citizen shares in judicial and deliberative office (Politics, Book III).
- Residence, the right to sue, descent or exile do not alone make a citizen.
- The state is later in time than the family but prior in nature.
- The whole is necessarily prior to the part.
Slaves and resident aliens live in the city but share no office. So residence is not enough. The household, village and polis grow in time, but the polis is the end towards which they grow, so it is first in nature.
Test yourself: Who said the state is later in time but prior in nature?
- Thrasymachus
- Aristotle
- Cephalus
- Plato
Answer: B. Aristotle, Politics Book I.
Machiavelli
The Prince and dual morality
The Prince is a manual for a ruler. It separates politics from private morality.
- Dual morality: one standard for private life, another for statecraft.
- It is secular, not religious in approach.
- It supports a citizen army over mercenaries.
- It is advice to a ruler, not a democratic work.
The Prince was written in 1513. It studies how power is won and held. Machiavelli says a prince who must survive in a corrupt world cannot always follow ordinary morals. He praises citizen soldiers because mercenaries are disloyal and weak.
Test yourself: Which statements about The Prince are correct?
- Democratic spirit and anti-secular
- Dual morality and a citizen army
- Anti-secular and citizen army
- Democratic spirit and dual morality
Answer: B. Only dual morality and the citizen army are true.
Republic, virtu and key elements
Machiavelli's own choice is the republic. His key ideas are republicanism, power and the classification of regimes.
- Ideal form of government: republic.
- Discourses on Livy praise the Roman mixed constitution.
- Virtu is the skill and boldness to act and succeed.
- Key elements: classification of regimes, republicanism, analysing power.
The clash of classes in Rome produced liberty and stability. A mixed constitution of consuls, senate and tribunes lasts longer than monarchy. Machiavelli also says civic virtue is indispensable to the citizen and the state. He is a pioneer of the study of power.
| Work | Mood |
|---|---|
| The Prince | Advice to a new ruler |
| Discourses on Livy | Praise of the Roman republic |
| The Art of War | Citizen militia |
Test yourself: Which form of government is ideal for Machiavelli?
- Republic
- Aristocracy
- Democracy
- Hereditary monarchy
Answer: A. Machiavelli praised the Roman republic with its mixed constitution.
Machiavelli's works and pagan revival
Three books and one view of religion are often asked about Machiavelli.
- The Prince, 1513.
- The Art of War, 1521.
- Discourses on Livy and History of Florence.
- M. B. Foster: his thought is more a pagan revival than a Protestant one.
The Art of War is a dialogue on how a republic should train its army. He admires the civic virtue and martial spirit of ancient Rome. He says Christian humility makes men weak. He judges religion by its use for the state. Discourse on Inequality is Rousseau's book.
Test yourself: Which book is NOT written by Machiavelli?
- Art of War
- The Discourses on Livy
- Discourses on Inequality
- The Prince
Answer: C. Discourse on Inequality was written by Rousseau in 1755.
Machiavelli: ends and means
Machiavelli judges a ruler by results. His end is a strong and united state.
- The popular summary is that the end justifies the means.
- The Prince aims at the unity and integrity of the state.
- The last chapter calls for a united Italy.
Machiavelli says harsh methods can be used when a state is in danger. The test is the safety of the state, not private morals. He wrote for a divided Italy that needed a strong ruler.
Test yourself: What was the key objective of The Prince?
- Unity and integrity of the state
- Private virtue
- Rule of the church
- Equality
Answer: A. A strong united state is the aim.
Confucius
Confucius and the Analects
The Analects are the sayings of Confucius, compiled by his disciples after his death.
- Core ideas: ren (humaneness) and li (ritual propriety).
- The ruler leads by moral example, not by force.
- Order comes from right relationships.
- The Analects are the base of Confucian thought.
Confucius believed that society is held together by proper roles, such as ruler and subject or father and son. A good ruler is like a model that others follow. The Analects, with the Mencius, form the base of Chinese political tradition.
Test yourself: The Analects are related to
- Nicomachus
- Plato
- Confucius
- Chou dynasty
Answer: C. They are a collection of his sayings.
Confucian classics
Tradition credits Confucius with editing the Five Classics. The Analects were compiled by disciples.
- Book of Changes (Yijing), Book of Documents, Book of Songs.
- Book of Rites and Spring and Autumn Annals.
- There is no Confucian Book of Animals.
A list of books asks which were not written by Confucius. A Book of Animals does not exist in the Confucian canon. Summers and Winters is not a classic either. The real fifth title is Spring and Autumn Annals.
Test yourself: Which is NOT among the classics credited to Confucius?
- Book of Changes
- Book of Songs
- Book of Animals
- Book of Rites
Answer: C. No such classic exists.
Method
Inductive method: Aristotle and Machiavelli
The inductive method moves from observed facts to general rules. Some thinkers are tied to it.
- Plato is deductive and speculative.
- Aquinas is deductive and theological.
- Machiavelli is the clear case of the inductive method.
- Textbooks credit Aristotle as the first to use it, but unplanned.
Aristotle studied 158 constitutions, but his use of induction is taken as unplanned. Machiavelli used history and experience on purpose. The two facts are both true, but the second does not explain the first. Hobbes, by contrast, reasoned deductively from definitions, like geometry.
| Thinker | Method |
|---|---|
| Plato | Deductive, from Ideas down |
| Aquinas | Deductive and theological |
| Machiavelli | Inductive, from history |
| Hobbes | Deductive, geometric reasoning |
Test yourself: Which thinker is the clear case of the inductive method?
- Plato
- Aquinas
- Machiavelli
- Hobbes
Answer: C. Machiavelli drew rules from history. Plato, Aquinas and Hobbes reasoned deductively.
🔨 Hegel, Marx and Marxism
Hegel's state and history, Marx's dialectics, alienation and stages, then Lenin, Gramsci and Mao.
Hegel
Hegel: state, civil society and Philosophy of Right
Hegel treats the state as the highest form of ethical life. Civil society sits between family and state.
- Philosophy of Right appeared in 1821, with 1820 on the title page.
- Ethical life has family, civil society and state.
- State is the march of God on earth.
- The rational is the real and the real is the rational.
Hegel did not reject civil society. He analysed it as a separate sphere. He placed women mainly in the family, the sphere of feeling, and men in civil society and state. The will is free when its ends are its own, so freedom is self-determination.
| Item | Hegel |
|---|---|
| Philosophy of Right | 1821 |
| State | March of God on earth |
| Civil society | Separate sphere between family and state |
| Women | Placed in the family |
Test yourself: When was Hegel's Philosophy of Right published?
- 1820
- 1821
- 1827
- 1837
Answer: B. It appeared in 1821 although the title page says 1820.
Hegel on war
Hegel does not treat war as a pure evil. He sees it as a moment in the life of the state.
- War is not an evil but a virtue.
- War shows the irony of the divine idea.
- War destroys the selfish egoism of the individual.
- The state of war shows the omnipotence of the state.
Hegel says war preserves the ethical health of nations, like winds that keep the sea from stagnation. It lifts individuals above private interest. The statement that humanity never needed war is not his.
Test yourself: Which statement does NOT fit Hegel on war?
- War destroys selfish egoism
- War shows the irony of the divine idea
- Humanity never needed war
- War is not purely an evil
Answer: C. Hegel saw war as part of ethical life.
Hegel: stages of absolute consciousness
In the Phenomenology of Spirit, the absolute reveals itself in four stages.
- Simple consciousness.
- Self-consciousness.
- Reason.
- Spirit.
Each stage grows out of the one before. Simple consciousness is awareness of an object. Self-consciousness is awareness of oneself. Reason unites self and world. Spirit is shared, social consciousness leading to absolute knowing.
Test yourself: Which is the order of the stages?
- Simple, Self, Reason, Spirit
- Reason, Self, Spirit, Simple
- Spirit, Simple, Self, Reason
- Self, Reason, Simple, Spirit
Answer: A. The ladder runs simple, self, reason and spirit.
Hegel: theory of the state and dialectical idealism
Hegel sees the state as the highest ethical form. His idealism is dialectical.
- State: a super-organism, an end in itself, the march of God on earth.
- It is unchecked by outside moral law, because it creates morality.
- Dialectical idealism: Spirit unfolds as thesis, antithesis, synthesis.
- Phenomenology of Spirit, 1807. Philosophy of Right, 1821.
For Hegel the state is the working of reason in history. Marx was strongly influenced by Hegel's dialectic. Climate change mitigation has no place in Hegel. Every individual is a child of his time, he wrote in the preface to the Philosophy of Right.
Test yourself: Which is true of Hegel?
- He wrote Phenomenology of Spirit
- He promoted climate mitigation
- He opposed the dialectic
- He taught Marx's materialism
Answer: A. Published 1807.
Hegel: art, religion and philosophy
For Hegel, art, religion and philosophy differ in form, not in content. All three express Absolute Spirit.
- Art knows the Absolute through sense and image.
- Religion knows it through story and feeling.
- Philosophy knows it through pure thought, the highest form.
The content is the same truth. Only the way of grasping it differs. Philosophy is highest because it grasps truth as concept.
Test yourself: In Hegel, philosophy knows the Absolute through
- Pure thought
- Sense image
- Story
- Feeling
Answer: A. Concept is the highest form.
Marx
Dialectical and historical materialism
Marx took Hegel's dialectic and put matter, not ideas, at the base.
- Hegel: ideas drive history. Marx: ideas are the result of material conditions.
- Dialectical materialism holds that matter and motion are inseparable.
- Laws of dialectics applied to social life give historical materialism.
- Marx turned Hegel right side up.
The dialectic is a movement through conflict of opposites. Marx applied it to society. Contradiction between forces and relations of production drives change. Engels helped to shape the laws: unity of opposites, quantity into quality, negation of the negation.
Test yourself: Application of the laws of dialectics in social life is shown through
- Social materialism
- Economic materialism
- Historical materialism
- Cultural materialism
Answer: C. Historical materialism is dialectics applied to society.
Stages of history and the Marxist sequence
Marx gives five stages of history. Each is defined by its mode of production.
- Primitive communal society.
- Slave society.
- Feudal society.
- Capitalist society.
- Communist society.
Each stage ends when its class contradiction becomes too sharp: master and slave, lord and serf, bourgeoisie and proletariat. The last stage is classless. In the 2023 sequence, machine industry came first, then bourgeois society, then proletarians, then seizure of power, then the end of the state.
| Stage | Main classes |
|---|---|
| Slave | Master and slave |
| Feudal | Lord and serf |
| Capitalist | Bourgeoisie and proletariat |
| Communist | Classless |
Test yourself: What is the correct order of Marx's stages?
- Primitive, Slave, Feudal, Capitalist, Communist
- Slave, Primitive, Feudal, Capitalist, Communist
- Primitive, Feudal, Slave, Capitalist, Communist
- Feudal, Communist, Primitive, Slave, Capitalist
Answer: A. The first stage is primitive communal society.
Alienation
In the 1844 Manuscripts Marx describes four forms of alienation of the worker under capitalism.
- From the product.
- From the process of work.
- From species-being.
- From other humans and from nature.
The worker does not own what he makes. His work is forced, not creative. He loses his creative and social nature. Lukacs linked objectification to reification. Fromm studied alienation in modern consumer society. Marcuse wrote One-Dimensional Man.
| Item | Link |
|---|---|
| Theory of alienation | Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 |
| Alienation and objectification | George Lukacs |
| Contemporary alienation | Erich Fromm |
| One-dimensionalisation | Herbert Marcuse |
Test yourself: Alienated labour in Marx includes
- Product only
- Product and process only
- Species and nature only
- Product, process, species and nature
Answer: D. All four forms appear in the Manuscripts.
Contradictions of capitalism and Marx's own theories
Marx held that capitalism has inner contradictions that will finally destroy it.
- Exploitation of surplus value is the biggest contradiction.
- Workers create more value than their wages.
- Marx wrote on alienation, surplus value and dictatorship of the proletariat.
- The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State is by Engels.
Exploitation produces class conflict, crises and eventual revolution. In a communist society, nobody has one exclusive sphere of activity. Engels published the Origin in 1884.
Test yourself: Which is NOT a theory of Marx?
- Alienation
- Surplus value
- Dictatorship of the proletariat
- Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State
Answer: D. That book is by Engels.
Marx and Engels on women
Marx and Engels linked women's position to general emancipation and to private property.
- Women's emancipation is a measure of general emancipation.
- Engels, 1884, linked women's subordination to the rise of private property.
- The family must be judged in its historical setting.
- Marx assumed socialism would bring emancipation.
Hegel, before Marx, held women inferior in reason. Engels' full title is The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State. Marx did not say much more on women beyond assuming that socialism would free them.
Test yourself: Prior to Marx, which thinker showed gender bias in this passage?
- Hegel
- J. S. Mill
- Plato
- Mary Wollstonecraft
Answer: A. The passage begins with Hegel's view of women.
Praxis and the Theses on Feuerbach
Praxis is theory joined to practical action that changes the world.
- Theses on Feuerbach: eleven short notes written in 1845.
- Published after Marx's death, by Engels, in 1888.
- Thesis XI: the point is to change the world.
- Praxis later became central for Gramsci, Lukacs and the Frankfurt School.
Philosophers have only interpreted the world. Marx wanted theory that moves people to act.
Test yourself: In which text is praxis most clearly developed?
- Theses on Feuerbach
- Capital
- Holy Family
- Value, Price and Profit
Answer: A. Eleven short theses of 1845.
Marx's works in order
Marx's works are asked in order of year of publication.
- The Holy Family, 1845.
- The German Ideology, written 1845-46.
- The Poverty of Philosophy, 1847.
- Critique of Political Economy, 1859.
The early works come first. Poverty of Philosophy replies to Proudhon. Value, Price and Profit was delivered in 1865 and published in 1898. The State and Revolution is Lenin, 1917.
| Work | Year |
|---|---|
| Holy Family | 1845 |
| Poverty of Philosophy | 1847 |
| Critique of Political Economy | 1859 |
| Value, Price and Profit | 1865 |
Test yourself: Which is the correct order?
- Holy Family, Poverty, Critique, Value
- Value, Holy Family, Critique, Poverty
- Critique, Value, Holy Family, Poverty
- Holy Family, Critique, Poverty, Value
Answer: A. The 1845 work is first and the 1865 lecture last.
Marx: materialism, surplus value and statelessness
Marx held that economic conditions drive history. Surplus value explains profit.
- Dialectical materialism: mass events are shaped by economic conditions.
- Production is the basic human activity; religion is the opium of the people.
- Surplus value extends Ricardo's labour theory; workers sell labour power.
- Marx was formally stateless: he gave up Prussian citizenship in 1845.
The worker sells labour power, the capacity of brain, muscle and nerve. Profit comes from labour time beyond what pays for it. Marx never took a new nationality and was refused British naturalisation in 1874. Exam note: the July 2018 surplus-value item was keyed to (a), (b) and (d).
Test yourself: Marx was formally a citizen of
- Germany
- France
- the UK
- None of these
Answer: D. He was stateless from 1845.
Marxism
Gramsci: hegemony and intellectuals
Hegemony is rule by consent. The ruling class makes its ideas look like common sense.
- Hegemony is the bourgeoisie's capacity to become the common sense of the age.
- Rule uses both coercion and consent.
- Organic intellectuals arise from a class and give it a worldview.
- Intellectuals are the dominant group's deputies.
Culture, schools, church and media spread the ruling class's ideas. Gramsci rejected economic or scientific determinism. Revolution needs political and intellectual struggle and counter-hegemony. He called his approach the philosophy of praxis.
Test yourself: Who rejected scientific determinism and urged political and intellectual struggle?
- Marx
- Gramsci
- Lenin
- Engels
Answer: B. Gramsci said revolution needs cultural leadership.
Gramsci: war of manoeuvre, position, progress
Gramsci borrowed war words for political strategy and criticised the idea of progress as a law.
- War of manoeuvre: direct attack on the state.
- War of position: long struggle in civil society.
- Progress is an ideology. Becoming is a philosophical conception.
- His Prison Notebooks were written in jail from 1929.
A war of manoeuvre suited Russia, where civil society was weak. A war of position suits the West, where civil society is strong. Progress depends on a specific mentality, and becoming can exist without progress.
| War | Target |
|---|---|
| Manoeuvre | Direct attack on the state |
| Position | Civil society, long struggle |
Test yourself: War of manoeuvre and war of position are linked with
- Fanon
- Mao
- Gramsci
- Marx
Answer: C. Both come from the Prison Notebooks.
Relative autonomy of the superstructure
Law, state and ideology are not a mere mirror of the economic base.
- Gramsci, Poulantzas, Mao and Althusser all give the superstructure some independence.
- Althusser is famous for the idea of relative autonomy.
- Mao: contradictions in the superstructure can drive change.
- Poulantzas: the capitalist state has relative autonomy.
Orthodox Marxism made ideas a simple reflection of the economy. These thinkers say the superstructure has a life of its own.
Test yourself: Which set of thinkers believes in relative autonomy of the superstructure?
- Althusser and Gramsci
- Poulantzas and Althusser
- Gramsci, Poulantzas, Mao
- Gramsci only
Answer: C. Gramsci, Poulantzas and Mao all hold it. This is the fullest set.
Gramsci: consent, civil society and the letters
Gramsci said rulers win by consent as well as force. Civil society is where hegemony is fought.
- Rival proletarian hegemony and manufacture of consent.
- State = political society plus civil society.
- Civil society is the ensemble of so-called private organisms.
- Terms civil society and political society come from Hegel.
- A Great and Terrible World: his letters, 1908 to 1926.
Schools, church and press spread the ruling class's ideas. The working class must build its own counter-hegemony. The statement that civil society is not the ensemble of private bodies is wrong.
Test yourself: Who spoke of a rival proletarian hegemony?
- Giddens
- Mill
- Lohia
- Gramsci
Answer: D. It is from the Prison Notebooks.
Lenin
Lenin and Trotsky
Lenin and Trotsky led the Russian Revolution but differed after 1924.
- What Is To Be Done, 1902: a disciplined vanguard party.
- The State and Revolution, 1917: Marxist theory of the state.
- What Is History is by E. H. Carr.
- Trotsky was assassinated in Mexico in 1940.
Trotsky founded the Red Army and lost the power struggle with Stalin. He was exiled in 1929 and settled in Mexico in 1937. A Stalinist agent, Ramon Mercader, struck him with an ice axe. He is known for permanent revolution.
Test yourself: Which Russian Marxist was assassinated in Mexico in 1940?
- Khrushchev
- Marx
- Stalin
- Trotsky
Answer: D. Trotsky died after an attack by Mercader.
Lenin: works in order, contributions and death
Lenin's works run from capitalism in Russia to war. He gave the vanguard party and the theory of imperialism.
- The Development of Capitalism in Russia, 1899.
- What Is To Be Done, 1902. Materialism and Empirio-Criticism, 1909.
- Socialism and War, 1915.
- Died 21 January 1924.
Lenin's contributions are the vanguard party, the plan to build the first workers' state and strategy and tactics of revolution. Imperialism for him is the highest stage of capitalism, not an intermediary stage.
Test yourself: In which year did Lenin die?
- 1919
- 1921
- 1924
- 1927
Answer: C. He died on 21 January 1924.
Mao
Mao: Cultural Revolution and war with politics
Mao tied war to politics and led the Cultural Revolution from 1966.
- Politics is war without bloodshed and war is politics with bloodshed.
- The Party commands the gun.
- Youth are masters of the new society.
- Poor peasants are the basic force. Feudal marriage is barbaric.
Mao answered Clausewitz by saying war never stands apart from politics. The Cultural Revolution drew on radical, anti-feudal and youth ideas. The idea that women are reserved for home-making does not fit it. The Little Red Book collects his quotations.
Test yourself: Who said politics is war without bloodshed?
- Mao Tse-Tung
- Hannah Arendt
- Frantz Fanon
- Hegel
Answer: A. Mao said it in his lectures on protracted war.
Mao: political work and the gun
Mao said politics must lead the economy and the Party must command the gun.
- Political work is the life blood of all economic work (1955).
- Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun (1938).
- The Party commands the gun, never the reverse.
Red comes before expert, and the mass line guides policy. The gun line comes from Problems of War and Strategy and reflects peasant-based armed struggle.
Test yourself: Who said political power grows out of the barrel of a gun?
- Stalin
- Mao Zedong
- Hobbes
- Machiavelli
Answer: B. Mao, 1938.
🌍 Modern, critical and postcolonial thought
Rawls, Arendt, Wollstonecraft, Fanon, the Frankfurt School, Foucault, Oakeshott and Said.
Rawls
Justice as fairness
Rawls offers justice as fairness as an alternative to utilitarianism.
- Justice is the first virtue of social institutions.
- Veil of ignorance in the original position.
- Primary social goods and pure procedural justice.
- Class in itself is Marx, not Rawls.
Utilitarianism could sacrifice a few for the many. Rawls says it does not take seriously the distinction between persons. Principles are chosen behind a veil of ignorance. Rights secured by justice are not open to political bargaining. He speaks of the basic structure of society, not of the state alone.
Test yourself: Who said justice is the first virtue of social institutions?
- Aristotle
- John Rawls
- Andrea Dworkin
- MacKinnon
Answer: B. It opens A Theory of Justice.
Rawls's works in order
Rawls's writings show his move from the domestic to the global.
- Justice as Fairness, 1958 essay.
- A Theory of Justice, 1971.
- Political Liberalism, 1993.
- The Law of Peoples, 1999.
Political Liberalism deals with justice in a plural society and overlapping consensus. The Law of Peoples extends the theory to international relations.
Test yourself: Which is the correct order?
- Justice as Fairness, Theory, Political Liberalism, Law of Peoples
- Law of Peoples, Theory, Fairness, Liberalism
- Theory, Law of Peoples, Fairness, Liberalism
- Fairness, Liberalism, Theory, Peoples
Answer: A. The 1958 essay comes first.
Rawls: difference principle, cooperative venture and veil
Rawls starts from free and equal individuals behind a veil of ignorance.
- Two principles: equal liberties; difference principle with fair opportunity.
- Society is a cooperative venture for mutual advantage.
- Behind the veil nobody knows class, talents or their conception of good.
- Rawls is an egalitarian, not an entitlement theorist or libertarian.
The parties do not know their place, status or natural assets. They also do not know their conception of the good. Justice as fairness flows from the individual as a free, rational person. Inequalities are allowed only if they help the least advantaged. The Law of Peoples (1999) extends his theory to international society.
Test yourself: Which is NOT implied by the veil of ignorance?
- No one knows his class
- No one knows his talents
- Parties know their conception of good
- No one knows his place
Answer: C. They do not know their conception of the good.
Arendt
The Human Condition and vita activa
Arendt divides active life into labour, work and action.
- Labour: biological necessity.
- Work: making durable objects, the craft of artists.
- Action: speech and deeds among equals in public.
- Action belongs to politics.
The Human Condition was published in 1958. Action is the highest activity and is linked to plurality and freedom. She feared that modern society reduced life to labour. The claim that action denies freedom of thought is false.
| Activity | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Labour | Lowest, for biological needs |
| Work | Durable things |
| Action | Highest, public speech among equals |
Test yourself: Arendt's three categories of vita activa are
- Capital, job, pleasure
- Desire, fulfilment, violence
- Labour, work, action
- Freedom, suffering, rights
Answer: C. These come from The Human Condition.
Arendt: works, totalitarianism and sayings
Arendt's books and her Socratic saying are common exam items.
- Origins of Totalitarianism 1951, Human Condition 1958.
- On Revolution 1963, On Violence 1970.
- It is better to suffer wrong than to do wrong.
- Bureaucratic terror: rule by nobody.
Origins studied Nazism and Stalinism. On Revolution compared the American and French revolutions. The American aimed at freedom and lasting institutions. The French was caught up in the social question and led to terror. Between Past and Future is her book of essays.
| Work | Year |
|---|---|
| Origins of Totalitarianism | 1951 |
| The Human Condition | 1958 |
| On Revolution | 1963 |
| On Violence | 1970 |
Test yourself: Who said it is better to suffer wrong than to do wrong?
- Gandhi
- Hannah Arendt
- Habermas
- Ambedkar
Answer: B. She took it from Socrates.
Wollstonecraft
Mary Wollstonecraft and the Vindication
Wollstonecraft is the founding voice of liberal feminism.
- A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, 1792.
- Women seem inferior because of poor education.
- Women should gain virtue by the same means as men.
- She attacked Rousseau's view of educating women to please men.
Her earlier works are Thoughts on the Education of Daughters (1787) and A Vindication of the Rights of Men (1790), a reply to Burke. Discourses on Education is not hers. Plato and Mill also favoured women's equality. Aristotle and Hegel did not.
Test yourself: Which pair did NOT believe in women's equality?
- Plato and Mill
- Aristotle and Hegel
- Mill and Wollstonecraft
- Plato and Wollstonecraft
Answer: B. Both saw women's place as secondary.
Wollstonecraft: rights of women and her age
Wollstonecraft claimed the same rights and education for women. Every thinker is shaped by an age.
- A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, 1792.
- Women should share the rights and privileges of men.
- Hegel: every individual is a child of his time.
She argued that women's weakness comes from poor education. The remark that every thinker is a child of the age is true, but it does not explain her argument.
Test yourself: Who wrote A Vindication of the Rights of Woman?
- Beauvoir
- Mary Wollstonecraft
- Friedan
- Millett
Answer: B. Published in 1792.
Fanon
Fanon: violence and Black Skin, White Masks
Fanon was a psychiatrist from Martinique who wrote on colonialism and racism.
- The Wretched of the Earth, 1961, has a preface by Sartre.
- Black Skin, White Masks, 1952.
- Violence is cathartic and recreates the colonised.
- The peasantry is a key agent. Warns of the national bourgeoisie.
Black Skin chapters include The Negro and Language, Psychopathology and Recognition, not The Negro and Culture. Colonialism is itself built on violence, so counter-violence frees the mind. Fanon is the thinker of anti-colonial struggle.
Test yourself: Who wrote the preface to The Wretched of the Earth?
- Marcuse
- Arendt
- Jean-Paul Sartre
- Sabine
Answer: C. Sartre's preface is famous.
Frankfurt School
The Frankfurt School and critical theory
The Institute for Social Research was set up in 1923. Its thinkers joined Marx with psychology.
- Fromm: Escape from Freedom, 1941.
- Adorno: The Authoritarian Personality, 1950.
- Marcuse: One-Dimensional Man, 1964.
- Habermas: leader of the second generation.
Fromm argued people gain freedom but feel alone, so they run to authoritarian leaders. The Authoritarian Personality introduced the F-scale. Habermas wrote on the public sphere, communicative action and Towards a Rational Society (1970).
| Thinker | Work |
|---|---|
| Fromm | Escape from Freedom |
| Adorno | Authoritarian Personality |
| Marcuse | One-Dimensional Man |
| Habermas | Public sphere |
Test yourself: Who is the leading exponent of the second generation of the Frankfurt School?
- Hegel
- Marx
- Lenin
- Jurgen Habermas
Answer: D. He was Adorno's assistant.
Neo-Marxism and the Frankfurt School
Neo-Marxists reworked Marx with culture and psychology. Luxemburg was a classical Marxist.
- Neo-Marxists: Habermas, Fromm, Marcuse.
- Rosa Luxemburg is not Neo-Marxist.
- Frankfurt Institute for Social Research, 1923.
Western or Neo-Marxism turned to culture, psychology and philosophy after the First World War. Luxemburg wrote on revolution, imperialism and the mass strike, and she died in January 1919.
Test yourself: Who is NOT related to Neo-Marxism?
- Habermas
- Fromm
- Marcuse
- Rosa Luxemburg
Answer: D. She was a classical Marxist.
Foucault
Foucault: knowledge and power
Foucault links knowledge to power and rewrites how history is done.
- Knowledge and power are bound together.
- The Archaeology of Knowledge, 1969.
- History turns documents into monuments.
- Archaeology describes the monument from inside.
Old history treated documents as voices to interpret. The new history describes and orders them. In the assertion-reason item both are correct and R explains A.
Test yourself: Who argued that knowledge and power are bound together?
- Plato
- Machiavelli
- Foucault
- Russell
Answer: C. Foucault linked power and knowledge. Russell defined power as producing intended effects.
Oakeshott
Michael Oakeshott
Oakeshott was a conservative English philosopher who criticised political rationalism.
- Experience and Its Modes, 1933.
- Introduction to Leviathan, 1946.
- Rationalism in Politics, 1962.
- On Human Conduct, 1975; The Voice of Liberal Learning.
He separates civil association from enterprise association. The History of England is not his. Putnam wrote Bowling Alone and Weber wrote The Protestant Ethic.
Test yourself: Which book is NOT by Oakeshott?
- Experience and its Modes
- Rationalism in Politics
- The History of England
- Introduction to Leviathan
Answer: C. That title is not his.
Postcolonial
Edward Said and Orientalism
Said founded postcolonial theory with Orientalism, 1978.
- Western knowledge made the Orient look backward and exotic.
- This Other justified colonial rule.
- Knowledge and power are linked, an idea from Foucault.
- Said was a Palestinian-American.
Said gave a humanist critique of the Enlightenment that uncovered its links to colonialism.
Test yourself: Who developed a humanist critique of the Enlightenment's links to colonialism?
- Aristotle
- Edward Said
- Woodrow Wilson
- Subhash Bose
Answer: B. It sums up Orientalism.
📚 Books, authors and orders
Matching thinkers to books, ideas and quotes, and putting births and books in order.
Orders
Order of birth and books
Many items ask births or books in order of date.
- Births: Aristotle 384 BC, Machiavelli 1469, Hobbes 1588.
- Then Locke 1632, Rousseau 1712.
- Leviathan 1651, Two Treatises 1689, Social Contract 1762, Province of Jurisprudence 1832.
- Social Contract 1762, Vindication 1792, Philosophy of Right 1820 (title page), Manuscripts 1844, On Liberty 1859.
The Human Condition (1958) is followed by The Archaeology of Knowledge (1969), After Virtue (1981) and Spheres of Justice (1983). The German Ideology, State and Revolution (1917), The Political System (1953) and Kuhn (1962) form another set.
| Thinker | Born |
|---|---|
| Aristotle | 384 BC |
| Machiavelli | 1469 |
| Hobbes | 1588 |
| Locke | 1632 |
| Rousseau | 1712 |
Test yourself: Which is the correct order of birth?
- Aristotle, Machiavelli, Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau
- Rousseau, Locke, Hobbes, Machiavelli, Aristotle
- Machiavelli, Aristotle, Locke, Hobbes, Rousseau
- Aristotle, Hobbes, Machiavelli, Locke, Rousseau
Answer: A. Ancient first, then Renaissance, then contract thinkers.
Match thinkers with books and ideas
Thinker-book matches are the most common item type in this unit.
- Gramsci: Prison Notebooks. Rawls: Political Liberalism, Theory of Justice.
- Arendt: Human Condition, Between Past and Future, On Violence.
- Berlin: Vico and Herder. Sandel: Tyranny of Merit.
- Marcuse: Reason and Revolution. King: Where Do We Go from Here.
Others are Russell Kirk (Conservative Mind) and Habermas (Towards a Rational Society). Hegel wrote Philosophy of Right and Lenin wrote State and Revolution. Locke wrote Letter on Toleration and Mill wrote Representative Government. Marx wrote German Ideology and Derrida wrote The Post Card.
| Author | Book |
|---|---|
| Mao | Little Red Book |
| Galbraith | The Affluent Society |
| Putnam | Bowling Alone |
| Weber | Protestant Ethic |
Test yourself: Which book is by Rawls?
- A Theory of Justice
- Philosophy of Right
- Towards a Rational Society
- State and Revolution
Answer: A. 1971.
Who said it and which statements are correct
Quotes and statement sets test careful reading.
- Sabine: Aristotle's ideal state is Plato's second best.
- Mill: rights so that people may not be misgoverned.
- Hegel: the rational is the real.
- Mao wrote On People's Democratic Dictatorship, not Gramsci.
Politics among Nations is by Morgenthau, not Aristotle. Montesquieu's separation of powers marks the US, not Britain. Hobbes did not write Philosophy of Right.
Test yourself: Who wrote On People's Democratic Dictatorship?
- Gramsci
- Mao
- Lenin
- Fanon
Answer: B. Mao wrote it in 1949.
Authors and books: more pairs
Matching items pair a thinker with a signature book.
- Warrender: The Political Philosophy of Hobbes (1957). Burke: Reflections on the Revolution in France.
- Hobbes: Leviathan. Kant: Critique of Pure Reason. Foucault: The Order of Things.
- Naomi Klein: On Fire. Weber: Economy and Society.
- Berlin: Four Essays on Liberty. Luxemburg: Social Reform or Revolution. Friedman: Capitalism and Freedom.
Wollstonecraft wrote the Vindication (1792) and Macpherson the Political Theory of Possessive Individualism (1962). Klein also wrote No Logo and The Shock Doctrine.
| Author | Book |
|---|---|
| Warrender | Political Philosophy of Hobbes |
| Macpherson | Possessive Individualism |
| Foucault | The Order of Things |
| Berlin | Four Essays on Liberty |
Test yourself: Who wrote Capitalism and Freedom?
- Milton Friedman
- Isaiah Berlin
- Max Weber
- Rosa Luxemburg
Answer: A. Friedman wrote it.
Critics of Marxism and historicism
Popper attacked the historicism of Plato, Hegel and Marx. Popper and Arendt called Marxism totalitarian.
- The Open Society and Its Enemies, 1945.
- Popper: belief in laws of history threatens freedom.
- Arendt: Origins of Totalitarianism, 1951.
- Gramsci was a Marxist, not a critic.
In his book Popper blames Plato in volume one and Hegel and Marx in volume two. Arendt studied Nazi and Stalinist rule.
Test yourself: Popper attacked the historicism of
- Plato and Aristotle
- Plato and Hegel
- Plato and Machiavelli
- Machiavelli and Marx
Answer: B. Plato, Hegel and Marx.
Practise Political Thought
All 177 past questions in this unit, with full explanations.
Practise this unit
⚖️ Social contract and liberal thought
Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, Paine and Mill: state of nature, consent, liberty and representation.
Hobbes
Human nature, power and motion
Hobbes was a materialist. For him life is motion, and people are driven by desire and fear.
The famous line is from Leviathan, Chapter 11. Everyone wants more power to satisfy desire. So the state of nature becomes a war of all against all. Only a sovereign can end it. Hobbes rejects any highest good that brings rest.
Test yourself: Who spoke of a perpetual and restless desire for power after power?
Answer: C. It is from Hobbes in Leviathan, Chapter 11.
Law as command and the science of politics
Hobbes defines law as a command of the sovereign. He also claims to have founded the science of politics.
A law is not advice. It is an order from someone with the right to command. The command itself is the reason to obey. Hobbes said natural science had Galileo and Harvey, while civil science began with him. Bentham and Austin later built on this idea.
Test yourself: With which book is the line, Law is the command of that person whose precept contains the reason of obedience, linked?
Answer: A. It is Hobbes's definition in De Cive.
Chapters of Leviathan in order
Part I of Leviathan, Of Man, builds up from sensation to reasoning in a ladder.
Sense gives impressions. Imagination keeps them. Speech names them and lets people think together. Reason and science use words to work out consequences. Only after this does Hobbes move to the passions.
Test yourself: Which is the correct order of the chapters?
Answer: A. The ladder runs from sense to speech and then to reason.
Hobbes: method, state of nature and obligation
Hobbes built politics on natural science. Without a sovereign, life is a war of all.
Hobbes wanted a science of politics as exact as geometry. In Leviathan Chapter 13 he describes life with no sovereign. The Taylor-Warrender thesis reads his laws of nature as moral duties commanded by God, while the older view stresses fear of punishment.
Test yourself: Who said life is solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short?
Answer: A. Leviathan, 1651.
Locke
Locke's state of nature, property and limited state
Locke's state of nature is peaceful. Government rests on consent and is limited.
Locke wrote An Essay Concerning Human Understanding in 1690. In politics he defends a limited state, bound by natural rights. People have a right to resist a government that breaks its trust. Popular sovereignty is usually credited to Rousseau, not Locke.
Test yourself: Which is incorrect about Locke?
Answer: D. The source of the state is consent.
Two Treatises: against Filmer and Hobbes
Locke's Two Treatises of Government, 1689, has two targets.
Filmer wrote Patriarcha. Locke had to refute both Filmer and Hobbes to build his new theory of state and obligation. Macpherson read Locke as a theorist of unlimited accumulation. Locke in fact set moral limits, so the second remark does not explain the first.
Test yourself: The Two Treatises are aimed against which two thinkers?
Answer: A. The First Treatise attacks Filmer. The Second answers Hobbes.
Locke: fiduciary trust and the contract
Locke's government is a trust. The people can remove a ruler who breaks it.
A trustee holds power for the public good. If the government takes property without consent, the trust is broken. Later generations stay members through their own consent, tacit or express, so it is false that they need not consent.
Test yourself: Which statement is NOT true of Locke's contract?
Answer: C. Later generations also consent.
Rousseau
Rousseau on inequality and equality
Rousseau separates natural inequality from conventional inequality. He wants wealth restrained.
The Discourse on Inequality was written in 1755. Rousseau says the second kind is man-made and so can be changed. In The Social Contract, Book II, he warns that extremes of wealth turn into political dependence. A rich man can buy the vote or labour of a poor man.
Test yourself: Who differentiated between natural and conventional inequality?
Answer: C. Rousseau did so in the Discourse on Inequality.
Rousseau's discourses on the arts and sciences
Rousseau's first major work says progress in sciences and arts corrupted morals.
Luxury, vanity and inequality came with polish and knowledge, he said. Natural simple man is better than civilised man. The theme is developed in the second discourse on inequality, 1755. The Social Contract and Emile came in 1762.
Test yourself: Who wrote the Discourse on the Moral Effects of the Arts and Sciences?
Answer: D. This was his 1750 prize essay.
Rousseau: general will, pride and English freedom
Rousseau's general will is the real will of citizens for the common good.
The will of all is only the sum of private wills. The general will asks what each would want as a citizen. Pride grows in society and seduces reason, which makes it incompatible with sympathy. Sovereignty is inalienable and indivisible, so it cannot be handed to representatives.
Test yourself: What is Rousseau's general will?
Answer: A. The real will aims at the common good.
Thomas Paine
Thomas Paine: necessary evil and Rights of Man
Paine saw government as a necessary evil and defended natural rights.
Paine wrote The Rights of Man to answer Edmund Burke's Reflections. His view of a minimal state is classic. Bentham saw government as a tool for utility. James Mill saw it as a protector with representation.
Test yourself: Who regarded the state as a necessary evil?
Answer: B. It is the line from Common Sense.
Social contract
Four thinkers, four ideas
Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau and Mill are each linked to one idea by the exam.
Hobbes gives the sovereign unlimited power to end the state of nature. Locke wants limited government by consent. Rousseau places the general will in the people. Mill defended proportional representation in Representative Government.
Test yourself: Which idea goes with Locke?
Answer: B. Locke wants a limited government that rests on consent.
J. S. Mill
Liberty and self-regarding actions
In On Liberty Mill divides actions into self-regarding and other-regarding.
Mill's idea of liberty is not doing whatever one wishes, and not the opposite either. It is the freedom to act so long as others are not harmed. The common criticism says almost every private act affects others, so the line cannot be held. Ernest Barker made that point.
Test yourself: Who said that we cannot separate two different compartments of individual conduct?
Answer: A. Barker criticised Mill's distinction.
Representative Government and proportional representation
Considerations on Representative Government, 1861, is about the ideal form of government.
Mill's economics is in the Principles of Political Economy, 1848. In Representative Government he wants every group to be heard. People need political rights not to govern but so that they may not be misgoverned.
Test yourself: In Representative Government Mill did NOT elaborate upon
Answer: D. Economics is in a different book.
Mill and women
Mill defended women's rights in writing and in Parliament.
Mill revised Bentham's utilitarianism and did not defend it in toto. He also did not defend patriarchy. Mill argued for wider participation, including women. He had worked for the East India Company until 1858.
Test yourself: J. S. Mill was a member of the British Parliament during
Answer: D. He was elected for Westminster in 1865 and lost in 1868.
Young Mill, the Romantics and Tocqueville
Mill grew up on a cold utilitarian doctrine and later turned to feeling.
The Romantic poets taught Mill that utilitarian psychology lacked human terms. Tocqueville showed him the sociological inadequacies of the doctrine, not scientific ones. Tocqueville analysed critically a concrete liberal democracy. Mill asked about the philosophical validity of liberalism.
Test yourself: Who among these espoused feeling and intuition that influenced Mill?
Answer: C. Mill's turn began with the Romantic poets.
Mill: free speech, higher pleasures and will
Mill defends free speech, ranks pleasures by quality and rests the state on willing support.
If the opinion is right, people lose truth. If wrong, they lose a clearer view of it. Bentham counted only quantity of pleasure. Mill added quality, so he is called a qualitative utilitarian. In the July 2018 item, will as the basis of institutions was keyed true.
Test yourself: Who held that some pleasures are of a higher quality?
Answer: D. This is his break from Bentham.
Bentham
Bentham and Carlyle's pig philosophy
Carlyle mocked utilitarianism as a pig philosophy. Happiness, he said, is more than pleasure.
Carlyle felt a doctrine that placed the satisfaction of appetite at the centre fit for swine. His reason, that happiness is more than pleasure, is why he used the insult.
Test yourself: Who called Bentham's utilitarianism pig philosophy?
Answer: B. Carlyle objected to a pleasure-only view.
Macpherson
Macpherson and possessive individualism
C. B. Macpherson coined possessive individualism. He saw it in Hobbes and Locke.
Macpherson argued that seventeenth-century liberal theory justified capitalism and unlimited accumulation. He was a Canadian political theorist.
Test yourself: Who coined possessive individualism?
Answer: C. He used it for Hobbes and Locke.