Unit 1: Political Theory mind map
Unit 1 of UGC NET Political Science is Political Theory. It asks what core ideas such as power, rights, liberty, equality and justice mean, and how the main ideologies and newer debates use them. Questions mostly ask who said a line, which thinker wrote which book, or which statements about an idea are correct. This map teaches each idea in plain words and puts the names, books and orders into tables. Each concept gives crisp points, a simple explanation, an everyday example, a table to memorise and a short self-test. Everything comes from past UGC NET Political Science papers.
Short of time? Start with Newer debates. It carries the most questions (52). Use the List view tab for a fast read the night before the exam.
All the notes in one place
This is the same content as the map, written out so you can read it from top to bottom. Open a branch to read it.
🏛️ Concepts of politics
Methods and approaches, power and authority, sovereignty, rights and citizenship: the building blocks the rest of the unit uses.
Approaches and power
Normative and empirical traditions
Political theory has two traditions. One asks what ought to be. The other studies what is.
- Normative or traditional: values, ethics, the good life, justice.
- Normative names: Strauss, Arendt, Jouvenal, Voegelin, Yves Simon.
- Empirical or behavioural: facts, groups, data, testing.
- Empirical names: Arthur Bentley, Robert Dahl, Charles Merriam.
The normative tradition reasons about values. It asks what a just state should be. The empirical tradition collects evidence about how politics actually works. Bentley studied pressure groups in The Process of Government. Dahl studied who really holds power in a city.
| Tradition | Question | Names |
|---|---|---|
| Normative | What ought to be | Strauss, Arendt, Voegelin, Jouvenal, Simon |
| Empirical | What is | Bentley, Dahl, Merriam |
| Historical | What was | Burke, Savigny |
Test yourself: Which of these thinkers belongs to the empirical or behavioural tradition?
- Eric Voegelin
- Yves Simon
- Robert Dahl
- Bertrand de Jouvenal
Answer: C. Dahl studied actual power in cities. The other three are normative thinkers.
Methods and Post-behaviouralism
Early writers listed methods of study. Easton later revolted against narrow technique.
- Comte: observation, experiment and comparison.
- Bluntschli: philosophical and historical methods.
- Behaviouralism stressed data, quantification and value-free study.
- Post-behaviouralism: Easton, 1969, called it a credo of relevance.
Auguste Comte wanted a positive science of society, built on observation, experiment and comparison. Bluntschli held that the study of the state needs both philosophy and history. By the 1960s many scholars used refined techniques on small problems. David Easton said relevance and action must come before technique. He wanted scholars to take part in social change.
| Stage | Main stress |
|---|---|
| Traditional | Values, institutions, history |
| Behavioural | Data, method, value-free |
| Post-behavioural | Relevance, action, social change |
Test yourself: Which statement is part of the post-behavioural credo?
- Techniques come before substance
- Social change should be the motto
- Politics must stay value-free
- Quantification matters most
Answer: B. Easton wanted relevance and change, not technique for its own sake.
Power: coercion and consent
Power is the ability to make others act as you wish. It works by force or by consent.
- Coercion is the hard side: threat, force, punishment.
- Consent is the soft side: accepted, legitimate rule.
- Weber links stable power to legitimacy.
- Gramsci calls rule by consent hegemony.
A state can make people obey by fear. That is costly and short-lived. When people accept the rule as right, less force is needed and the rule lasts longer. This is why legitimacy and hegemony matter in political theory.
Test yourself: Which statement about power is correct?
- It rests only on physical force
- It can rest on consent and be more effective
- It never needs legitimacy
- It is the same as authority
Answer: B. Power can be coercive or consensual, and consent often works better.
Authority and obedience
Authority is power accepted as right. Thinkers debate whether it should be obeyed without question.
- Authority demands obedience without asking for reasons.
- Critics say it can weaken reason and personal responsibility.
- Philosophical anarchism: no state in fact has legitimate authority.
- Political anarchism says the state should be abolished.
Unquestioning obedience can create a climate of deference and uncritical trust in others. That is the standard criticism. Philosophical anarchists such as R. P. Wolff and A. J. Simmons make a narrower claim. They say citizens have no general duty to obey the state just because it commands. They do not demand that the state disappear.
| View | Claim | Names |
|---|---|---|
| Political anarchism | Abolish the state | Proudhon, Bakunin, Kropotkin |
| Philosophical anarchism | No state has real authority | Wolff, Simmons |
Test yourself: What is the main argument of philosophical anarchism?
- No state should exist
- No state in fact has authority
- States should cooperate in harmony
- It supports liberal principles
Answer: B. It denies legitimate authority, not necessarily the state's existence.
Behaviouralism and the three phases
Political theory moved through three phases. Each phase answered the one before it.
- Traditional theory is prescriptive and normative: it asks what ought to be.
- Behavioural theory seeks uniformities and regularities through observed facts.
- Post-behavioural theory stands for relevance and action; it is holistic.
- Easton: behaviouralism is an intellectual tendency and an academic movement.
Traditional theory, from Plato onward, reasons about the best state. After 1945 behaviouralists wanted a science of politics with testable generalisations. David Easton described behaviouralism in 1962 as both a tendency of thought and a concrete movement. In 1969 he led the post-behavioural revolt, which brought values back.
| Phase | Concern | Key name |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional | Values, ought | Plato, Aristotle |
| Behavioural | Facts, regularities | Dahl, Almond, Merriam |
| Post-behavioural | Relevance and action | Easton, 1969 |
Test yourself: Which statement about post-behavioural theory is NOT correct?
- It is tied to action
- It stresses relevance
- It is not holistic
- It brings values back
Answer: C. Post-behavioural theory takes a broad, joined-up view, so calling it not holistic is wrong.
Decline and revival of political theory
In the 1950s some writers said political theory was dying. Berlin argued it cannot die.
- Causes of decline: historicism, positivism, moral relativism and hyperfactualism.
- Berlin: Does Political Theory Still Exist? (1962).
- Berlin: politics is about colliding ends, so theory has no end.
- Berlin blames rank empiricists for the decline, and is not sceptical of its revival.
Historicism treats ideas as products of their age. Positivism counts only what can be tested. Moral relativism makes values mere opinion. Hyperfactualism piles up facts without ideas. Berlin replied that where people disagree on ends, they must reason about ends, so political theory continues.
Test yourself: Which is NOT a cause given for the decline of political theory?
- Historicism
- Positivism
- Hyperfactualism
- Idealism
Answer: D. The four causes are historicism, positivism, moral relativism and hyperfactualism.
Ideology and key terms
An ideology is a belief system that guides action. It usually speaks for a class or group.
- Features: a political belief system, action-oriented, a world view of a group.
- Ideas with no class or social interest do not count as ideology.
- Marx: ideology legitimises the rule of the dominant class.
- Fascism: follow the leader. Mill supported women's rights.
Ideology links a picture of the world with a plan for action. It may preserve, change or overthrow the order. Marx wanted revolution against capitalism, not to protect the order. Radical feminists want to end patriarchy. Patriarchy means male power over women. Holism puts the whole above its parts.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Patriarchy | Power of men over women |
| Holism | The whole outweighs its parts |
| Deep ecology | Rejects anthropocentrism |
| Sustainable development | Meets present needs without harming the future |
Test yourself: Which is NOT a feature of ideology?
- A political belief system
- Action-oriented ideas
- A group's world view
- Ideas that serve no class or social interest
Answer: D. Ideology expresses the interests of a class or group.
Lukes' three dimensions of power
Steven Lukes found three faces of power. Each goes deeper than the last.
- First: decision-making, who wins open conflicts (Dahl).
- Second: non-decision making or agenda setting (Bachrach and Baratz).
- Third: thought control, shaping wants and beliefs.
- Capability enhancement is not one of the three.
In Power: A Radical View (1974) Lukes argued that power is not only winning a vote. It is also keeping issues off the agenda. At the deepest level, it shapes what people want, so they never raise a complaint.
| Face | Idea | Source |
|---|---|---|
| First | Decision-making | Dahl |
| Second | Agenda setting | Bachrach and Baratz |
| Third | Thought control | Lukes |
Test yourself: Which is NOT among Lukes' three forms of power?
- Decision-making
- Agenda setting
- Thought control
- Capability enhancement
Answer: D. His three are decisions, agenda setting and thought control.
Subaltern school and new democracy
The Subaltern school writes history from below. It takes its idea from Gramsci.
- Subaltern means a subordinate group: peasants, workers, Dalits, women.
- Ranajit Guha and the Subaltern Studies group began the school.
- The exam links "new democracy" as hegemony of the marginalised to this school.
Gramsci used the word subaltern for groups outside the ruling elite. The Subaltern Studies group applied it to Indian history. They argued that peasants and workers made politics in their own right and that the elite did not.
Test yourself: The school that writes history from below, from the view of peasants and workers, is called
- Subaltern
- Post-behavioural
- Positivist
- Liberal
Answer: A. Subaltern means subordinate groups, whose view this school takes.
Sovereignty
Sovereignty and its evolution
Sovereignty is the supreme power of a state. Textbooks teach it in four stages.
- Legal sovereignty: Austin, the lawmaker whose command is final.
- Political sovereignty: Dicey, the electorate behind the lawmaker.
- Popular sovereignty: the people are the final source of authority.
- Plural sovereignty: Laski, Figgis, Cole share authority among groups.
Austin saw sovereignty as a determinate person or body whose commands are law. Dicey added the electorate behind the legal sovereign. Rousseau's popular sovereignty places the final source in the people. Pluralists in the early twentieth century said the state is only one association among many.
| Type | Idea | Name |
|---|---|---|
| Legal | Final lawmaker | Austin |
| Political | Electorate behind law | Dicey |
| Popular | People as source | Rousseau |
| Plural | Shared among groups | Laski, Figgis, Cole |
Test yourself: Who is linked with plural sovereignty?
- Austin
- Dicey
- Laski
- Bodin
Answer: C. Laski, Figgis and Cole argued that authority is shared among groups.
Rights
Theories of rights
Thinkers disagree on where rights come from. Each theory gives a different answer.
- Natural rights: inherent, inalienable, prior to the state. Locke.
- Legal rights: created and enforced by law. Bentham.
- Social-welfare view: rights are conditions for growth. Laski, Green.
- Bentham called natural rights nonsense upon stilts.
Locke held that life, liberty and property exist before any government. Bentham, a utilitarian, answered that a right exists only if law creates and enforces it. Laski took a third route. He said rights are social conditions that help each person be their best self, so they come from the community.
| Theory | Source of rights | Name |
|---|---|---|
| Natural | Human nature | Locke |
| Legal | Law and enforcement | Bentham, Austin |
| Social welfare | Community needs | Laski, Green, Hobhouse |
Test yourself: Who called natural rights rhetorical nonsense?
- J. S. Mill
- Adam Smith
- Herbert Spencer
- Jeremy Bentham
Answer: D. Bentham attacked the French Declaration in Anarchical Fallacies.
Laski and Hobhouse on rights
Laski and Hobhouse treat rights as social. Rights come with duties and the common good.
- Laski: every state is known by the rights it maintains.
- Laski: rights are social conditions for being one's best self.
- Hobhouse: rights are what we may expect from others and others from us.
- No right can exist against the social interest.
Laski wrote A Grammar of Politics in 1925. He rejects the idea of a lost historic grant of rights. Rights are conditions that society recognises because they help every person grow. A claim that harms society cannot be a right. Hobhouse adds that every right is matched by a duty.
Test yourself: Who said that every state is known by the rights that it maintains?
- Green
- Hegel
- Laski
- Barker
Answer: C. The line is from Laski's A Grammar of Politics.
Rights against the state and criticism of human rights
Rights are most useful as a shield against the state. Human rights also face criticism.
- A theory with no rights against the state is no theory of rights.
- Critics say human rights favour the individual over the group.
- Communitarians, Marxists and Asian-values writers lead the criticism.
- Rights belong where individual and state claims conflict.
The classic liberal picture treats the state as the body that can most easily take liberty away. So a right matters when it can be claimed against it. Critics reply that rights make people look like isolated owners. Marxists add that the rights of man mainly protect property owners.
Test yourself: Human rights are criticised for
- Placing collectivism above individualism
- Placing individualism above collectivism
- Equating the two
- Opposing both
Answer: B. Critics say they favour the individual over the community.
Human rights documents and the right to die
Human rights grew through documents, one after another. Their order is a favourite question.
- 1948: Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
- 1966: International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
- 1969: American Convention on Human Rights.
- 1979: CEDAW on discrimination against women.
A declaration states principles. A covenant is a treaty that binds states that ratify it. Minoo Masani founded the Society for the Right to Die with Dignity in 1981. The Supreme Court later allowed passive euthanasia in principle in Aruna Shanbaug (2011).
| Document | Year |
|---|---|
| UDHR | 1948 |
| ICCPR | 1966 |
| American Convention | 1969 |
| CEDAW | 1979 |
Test yourself: Which document came first?
- CEDAW
- American Convention
- ICCPR
- UDHR
Answer: D. The UDHR was adopted in 1948.
Citizenship
Citizenship and its theories
Citizenship is full membership of a state. Its meaning keeps widening.
- Marshall: civil, political and social rights.
- Citizens can be born or made by naturalisation.
- Living in a territory does not make someone a citizen.
- Cosmopolitans extend citizenship beyond the nation-state.
T. H. Marshall described citizenship as a ladder of rights. Bryan Turner is known for a typology of citizenship that links it to social conflict. Herman van Gunsteren is cited for the remark that citizenship had gone out of fashion among political thinkers. Cosmopolitans such as Kant argue that every person has rights as a world citizen.
| Thinker | Contribution |
|---|---|
| T. H. Marshall | Civil, political, social rights |
| B. S. Turner | Typology of citizenship, social conflict |
| Van Gunsteren | Citizenship out of fashion |
| Kant | Cosmopolitan right |
Test yourself: Which sociologist is known for a typology of citizenship linked to social conflict?
- T. H. Marshall
- Giddens
- B. S. Turner
- David Held
Answer: C. Turner built a typology of citizenship. Marshall is known for the three kinds of rights.
⚖️ Liberty, equality and justice
The three big values of political theory: two meanings of liberty, natural and social inequality, and the main theories of justice.
Liberty
Negative and positive liberty
Isaiah Berlin split liberty into two ideas. One means freedom from interference. The other means freedom to develop.
- Negative liberty: absence of constraints imposed by others.
- Positive liberty: real capacity to realise one's potential.
- Positive liberty allows the state to help, for example by schooling.
- Green, Laski, Rousseau and Hegel lean positive. Locke and Bentham lean negative.
For negative liberty the question is how much is left alone. For positive liberty the question is who controls my life and whether I have the means to act. A hungry or uneducated person has little real freedom, so welfare liberals ask the state to remove those obstacles.
| Type | Meaning | Supporters |
|---|---|---|
| Negative | No interference | Locke, Bentham, Hayek |
| Positive | Capacity and self-mastery | Green, Laski, Rousseau |
Test yourself: Who among these is NOT a supporter of positive liberty?
- T. H. Green
- Harold Laski
- Jeremy Bentham
- Rousseau
Answer: C. Bentham defended negative liberty, protection from interference.
Books and freedoms
Several works on liberty and Roosevelt's list of freedoms are favourite factual items.
- Berlin, Two Concepts of Liberty, 1958.
- Hayek, The Constitution of Liberty, 1960.
- Berlin, Four Essays on Liberty, 1969.
- Roosevelt's four freedoms: speech, worship, from want, from fear.
Berlin delivered Two Concepts of Liberty as his Oxford lecture in 1958. Hayek's book followed in 1960. Berlin reprinted the lecture in Four Essays on Liberty in 1969. Roosevelt named four freedoms in his January 1941 message. Freedom against exploitation is in the Indian Constitution, not in his list.
| Work | Author | Year |
|---|---|---|
| Two Concepts of Liberty | Berlin | 1958 |
| The Constitution of Liberty | Hayek | 1960 |
| Four Essays on Liberty | Berlin | 1969 |
Test yourself: Which freedom did Roosevelt NOT mention?
- Speech
- Worship
- Fear
- Against exploitation
Answer: D. His list was speech, worship, want and fear.
Property and liberty
Some thinkers say property protects liberty. Others say it destroys the liberty of the poor.
- Locke: property is a natural right that liberty protects.
- Rousseau: the first fencing of land began inequality.
- Marx and Engels: owners dominate those who own nothing.
- Hayek and Nozick defend property as the base of freedom.
Liberals see property as the guarantee of independence. Critics reverse the argument. If a few own the land and factories, the rest depend on them. Rousseau, Marx and Engels all hold that propertied classes can dominate the others.
Test yourself: Which thinker does NOT say propertied classes destroy liberty?
- Rousseau
- Marx
- Locke
- Engels
Answer: C. Locke treats property as a natural right to be protected.
Equality
Natural and conventional inequality
Rousseau divided inequality into two kinds. Only one comes from society.
- Natural or physical: age, health, strength, intelligence.
- Conventional or moral: wealth, honour, power.
- Source: Discourse on the Origin of Inequality, 1755.
- Rousseau blames private property for the second kind.
Nature creates differences of body and mind. Society creates differences of rank and wealth through agreement. Rousseau's complaint is aimed at the second kind because it can be changed. The first cannot.
Test yourself: Which two kinds of inequality did Rousseau distinguish?
- Political and social
- Natural and conventional
- Conservative and radical
- Legal and moral only
Answer: B. Natural and conventional, in the 1755 Discourse.
Economic equality and capabilities
Equality is more than the vote. Laski and Sen ask what equality really needs.
- Laski: political equality is unreal without economic equality.
- Wealth turns into political power.
- Sen asks equality of what, and answers with capabilities.
- Sen: equality is a partial guide to goodness, not the whole.
One person, one vote looks equal. But a rich donor has far more influence than a poor voter. Laski wanted at least a minimum of economic security. Amartya Sen asked which thing should be equal and chose basic capabilities, the real things people can do and be.
| Thinker | Equality of what |
|---|---|
| Laski | Economic security behind political equality |
| Sen | Basic capabilities |
| Rawls | Primary goods, difference principle |
Test yourself: Who said political equality is never real without virtual economic equality?
- J. S. Mill
- H. J. Laski
- Kautsky
- Cobban
Answer: B. Laski made this argument in A Grammar of Politics.
Justice
Distributive justice and Rawls
Distributive justice is about how benefits and burdens are shared. Aristotle and Rawls are the anchors.
- Aristotle: distributive and corrective justice.
- Distribution by merit; equals get equal shares.
- Rawls: justice as fairness, difference principle.
- Inequality is allowed only if it helps the worst off.
Aristotle said honours and wealth should be shared in proportion to worth. Rawls, in A Theory of Justice, asks what rules free and equal people would choose behind a veil of ignorance. He allows inequality only when it benefits the least advantaged, so he is called an egalitarian liberal.
| Thinker | Idea |
|---|---|
| Aristotle | Distributive by merit, corrective for wrongs |
| Rawls | Justice as fairness |
| Nozick | Entitlement |
Test yourself: Who said that distributive justice is concerned with honours or wealth?
- Plato
- Aristotle
- Marx
- Gramsci
Answer: B. Aristotle divided justice into distributive and corrective.
Nozick's entitlement theory
Nozick says a holding is just if it came about justly. Patterns do not matter.
- Just initial acquisition.
- Just transfer: free gift, sale or exchange.
- Rectification of past injustice.
- There is no principle of final acquisition.
In Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974) Nozick judges justice by history, not by the shape of the distribution. If wealth was gained and passed on justly, any pattern is fair. So taxing it for redistribution is a violation of rights. He accepts only a minimal state.
Test yourself: Which is NOT a principle of Nozick's entitlement theory?
- Just transfer
- Just initial acquisition
- Final acquisition
- Rectification
Answer: C. His theory has three principles: acquisition, transfer, rectification.
Luck egalitarianism and justice with equality
Some theories say luck should not decide who is better off. Choices can.
- Luck egalitarianism: natural ability and birth are brute luck.
- Only choices and effort justify different rewards.
- Justice for all is compatible with equality.
- Justice also needs positive liberty, but that is a separate point.
Luck egalitarians say people should not gain or lose because of talent, family or accident. The state should compensate for bad luck. In the December 2022 item, equality and positive liberty are both linked to justice, but one does not explain the other.
Test yourself: Which concept says luck, including natural ability, should not affect distributive justice?
- Meritocracy
- Plutocracy
- Luck egalitarianism
- Aristocracy
Answer: C. It treats talent and birth as brute luck.
Global justice
Global justice asks whether duties of justice cross borders. Singer says yes. Nagel doubts it.
- Singer: Famine, Affluence and Morality (1972).
- Nagel: we do not live in a just world.
- Nagel doubts that justice duties cross borders.
- Global justice universalises liberalism to one political entity.
Peter Singer argued that if we can prevent something bad without losing anything of equal importance, we should. Distance or citizenship makes no moral difference. Thomas Nagel said the world is plainly unjust but that duties of justice may need a shared state. Leaders disagree about methods, not about the need to help.
| Thinker | Position |
|---|---|
| Singer | Duty to aid regardless of distance |
| Nagel | Unjust world, limited justice duties |
| Pogge | Global institutions harm the poor |
| Moellendorf | Liberal justice applies globally |
Test yourself: Who wrote Famine, Affluence and Morality?
- Thomas Nagel
- Peter Singer
- Darrel Moellendorf
- John Rawls
Answer: B. Singer wrote it in 1972.
Pareto optimality
Pareto's test of a good change is simple. Someone gains and nobody loses.
- Pareto improvement: better off for one, worse off for none.
- Pareto optimal: no such change is left.
- Vilfredo Pareto, Italian economist and sociologist (1848-1923).
- It never weighs one person's gain against another's loss.
Welfare economics uses the idea because it avoids hard comparisons between people. Its weakness is that a very unequal state can still be Pareto optimal, since fixing it may need someone to lose.
Test yourself: "Make someone better off without making anyone worse off" is whose principle?
- Pareto
- Nozick
- Foucault
- Rawls
Answer: A. This is Pareto optimality.
Justice theorists and their books
Matching items pair a justice thinker with a book or idea.
- Rawls: distributive justice. Nozick: justice as entitlement.
- Walzer: communitarian justice (Spheres of Justice). Pogge: global justice.
- Brian Barry: The Liberal Theory of Justice (1973).
- Okin: Justice, Gender and the Family (1989). Sen: The Idea of Justice (2009).
- Tom Campbell: Justice (1988).
Walzer says goods should be shared by the meanings each community gives them. Pogge argues that global rules keep the poor poor. Okin criticises Rawls for ignoring the family. Sen compares real situations instead of building an ideal state.
| Author | Book or idea |
|---|---|
| Brian Barry | The Liberal Theory of Justice |
| Okin | Justice, Gender and the Family |
| Sen | The Idea of Justice |
| Tom Campbell | Justice |
Test yourself: Who wrote Justice, Gender and the Family?
- Susan Moller Okin
- Brian Barry
- Tom Campbell
- Amartya Sen
Answer: A. Okin wrote it in 1989.
🧭 Ideologies
Liberalism and its offshoots, conservatism, the New Right and socialism: what each believes and who stands where.
Liberalism and the minimal state
Elements of liberalism
Liberalism puts the individual first. It trusts reason, limits government and welcomes plural society.
- The individual may develop his or her own personality.
- Humans are rational creatures.
- Constitutionalism and limited government.
- Society should be plural, not uniform.
Classical liberals stress freedom from interference and the rule of law. Modern or social liberals such as T. H. Green and Rawls add that formal freedom is empty for a hungry or uneducated person. So they accept positive liberty and welfare.
| Type | Role of the state |
|---|---|
| Classical liberalism | Minimal, protect rights |
| Modern liberalism | Positive, welfare, social liberalism |
Test yourself: In which aspect does modern liberalism NOT believe?
- Social liberalism
- Positive freedom
- Cradle to grave welfare
- Minimal state
Answer: D. Modern liberals support an active welfare state.
Possessive individualism and autonomy
Macpherson called early liberalism possessive. Later liberals link freedom to autonomy.
- Macpherson: The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism, 1962.
- The individual is the owner of his own person and skills.
- Society becomes a market of owners.
- Autonomy is a skill that needs social and material conditions.
Macpherson read Hobbes and Locke as imagining people as owners who owe nothing to society for their capacities. Autonomy-based liberals such as Raz argue that people need resources and conditions to run their own lives. So the state has a role in supplying them.
Test yourself: How did C. B. Macpherson characterise early liberalism?
- Welfarist
- Possessive
- Altruistic
- Developmental
Answer: B. He called it possessive individualism.
Individualism and individualist anarchism
Individualists want a night-watchman state. Individualist anarchists want no state.
- State functions: law and order, defence, protecting property, valid contracts.
- Spencer and Adam Smith are classic individualists.
- Individualist anarchism: private property, ultra liberalism, civil disobedience.
- Organicism is not a feature of individualist anarchism.
The minimal state only protects life, property and contracts. In June 2023 the list of functions included protection from epidemics but not distribution of property. Individualist anarchists such as Stirner, Tucker and Thoreau want the individual to be sovereign.
Test yourself: Which is NOT a salient feature of individualist anarchism?
- Private property
- Ultra liberalism
- Civil disobedience
- Organicism
Answer: D. Organicism sees society as a body and is anti-individualist.
Phases of liberalism
Liberalism changed over time. Four phases are asked in order.
- Negative liberalism: Locke, Smith, Mill; freedom is no restraint.
- Positive liberalism: T. H. Green, Hobhouse; the state removes obstacles.
- Egalitarianism: Rawls, 1971; fair equality.
- Libertarianism: Nozick, Friedman; a minimal state again.
Classical liberals feared the state. New liberals said poverty and ignorance also limit freedom, so the state may act. Rawls built justice on fair shares. Libertarians then returned to the minimal state. Laski is a positive liberal, while Friedman and Spencer favour little state action.
Test yourself: Which is the correct order of liberalism's phases?
- Negative, positive, egalitarian, libertarian
- Libertarian, negative, positive, egalitarian
- Positive, egalitarian, negative, libertarian
- Negative, egalitarian, positive, libertarian
Answer: A. Classical, then new liberal, then Rawls, then libertarian.
Communitarian critique of liberalism
Communitarians say people are shaped by their communities. They attack the liberal self.
- Walzer: liberalism is a self-subverting doctrine needing periodic correction.
- MacIntyre: After Virtue (1981). Sandel: Liberalism and the Limits of Justice.
- Charles Taylor and Walzer are also communitarians.
- Hayek is a liberal and not a communitarian.
Walzer argued that liberalism lets people leave every group, which weakens the ties on which liberal life rests. So it needs a communitarian correction from time to time. Communitarians mainly target Rawls.
| Thinker | Communitarian idea |
|---|---|
| Walzer | Spheres of Justice; liberalism self-subverting |
| MacIntyre | After Virtue; tradition |
| Sandel | Critique of the unencumbered self |
Test yourself: Who is NOT a communitarian?
- Michael Sandel
- Alasdair MacIntyre
- Michael Walzer
- Friedrich Hayek
Answer: D. Hayek is a liberal.
Libertarianism and Conservatism
Libertarianism and Nozick
Libertarians want a minimal state and maximum freedom. Markets beat planning.
- Nozick: Anarchy, State, and Utopia, 1974.
- Friedman: Capitalism and Freedom, 1962.
- Hayek: The Road to Serfdom, 1944.
- Dahl is a pluralist, not a libertarian.
Nozick first accepts the anarchist charge that a state violates rights and keeps a monopoly on force. He then argues that a minimal state can arise without violating anyone's rights. The state's motive being citizens' welfare is the incorrect argument.
| Thinker | Book |
|---|---|
| Hayek | The Road to Serfdom, 1944 |
| Friedman | Capitalism and Freedom, 1962 |
| Nozick | Anarchy, State, and Utopia, 1974 |
Test yourself: Who is NOT a supporter of libertarianism?
- Robert Nozick
- Milton Friedman
- Robert Dahl
- F. A. Hayek
Answer: C. Dahl is a pluralist theorist of democracy.
Conservatism
Conservatism trusts tradition and order over abstract reason.
- Core beliefs: tradition, hierarchy and authority.
- Founder: Edmund Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France.
- Others: Oakeshott. Hayek is often listed here because the New Right borrows conservative themes.
- T. H. Green is a new liberal, not a conservative.
- Burke accepted change only in order to conserve. Conservatives oppose revolution.
Burke said inherited institutions hold the wisdom of generations. Society is an organism with unequal parts, so rank and authority are natural. Social Darwinism and social liberalism are not core conservative beliefs.
Test yourself: Which are the central beliefs of conservatism?
- Tradition and social Darwinism
- Tradition and hierarchy
- Hierarchy and social liberalism
- Social Darwinism and liberalism
Answer: B. Tradition, hierarchy and authority are central.
New Right and Socialism
The New Right
The New Right revived free-market ideas against the welfare state.
- Austrian school: Menger, von Mises, Hayek.
- Chicago school: Friedman, Stigler.
- Thatcher and Reagan: deregulation, tax cuts, weaker unions.
- Welfare is said to create dependency; markets teach self-reliance.
The economic wing of the New Right has two schools. Friedman is the most prominent Chicago economist. In the December 2023 passage the New Right says the welfare state makes poor citizens passive dependants. The market, family and civic associations are seed beds of civic virtue. Strong trade unions are not favoured.
| School | Key names |
|---|---|
| Austrian | Menger, von Mises, Hayek |
| Chicago | Friedman, Stigler |
| Frankfurt | Adorno, Marcuse, not New Right |
Test yourself: Which are the schools of the New Right?
- Austrian and Chicago
- Austrian and New York
- Chicago and Frankfurt
- Austrian and Frankfurt
Answer: A. The Frankfurt school is a Marxist tradition.
Socialism
Socialism wants equality and social ownership. It takes many forms.
- Features: equality, curbs on competition, aim to end capitalism.
- It does not seek accumulation of private property.
- Ramsay Muir: socialism is a chameleon.
- Syndicalism: French, trade union based, accepts class struggle.
Socialism has no single fixed meaning, so Ramsay Muir called it a chameleon. Syndicalism arose in France with the CGT and Georges Sorel. It wants industry controlled by workers' unions and relies on class struggle. G. A. Cohen is an analytical Marxist who criticised Rawls.
Test yourself: Who defined socialism as a chameleon?
- C. E. M. Joad
- Emile
- Ramsay Muir
- Hugham
Answer: C. Muir used the image of a changing colour.
The end of history
Fukuyama said liberal democracy and the market have no rival left.
- The End of History? (1989), then a book in 1992.
- Fascism lost in 1945; communism collapsed around 1989-91.
- Liberal democracy is the final form of government.
- Huntington wrote the Clash of Civilizations.
Fukuyama argued that after the Cold War no serious ideology challenged liberal democracy with a market economy. Critics say history did not end. Other thinkers are often placed beside him in the options.
Test yourself: Who made the end of history thesis?
- Samuel Huntington
- Benjamin Barber
- Francis Fukuyama
- Alexander Wendt
Answer: C. Fukuyama made it.
Communism
Communism aims at a classless society with common ownership.
- Common ownership of the means of production.
- Equality and distribution by need.
- A classless society as the final goal.
- Lenin's vanguard party leads the workers.
Marx saw communism as the end of class exploitation. Lenin added the vanguard party of professional revolutionaries. A dictatorship of the priestly class has no place in communism. Marx spoke of a dictatorship of the proletariat.
Test yourself: Which is NOT an essential fact of communism?
- Common ownership
- Classless society
- Vanguard party
- Dictatorship of the priestly class
Answer: D. Marx spoke of the proletariat, not the priests.
Fabianism, guild socialism and syndicalism
Socialism has peaceful and radical forms. Match each with its method.
- Fabianism: peaceful, gradual change; the Webbs and Shaw.
- Guild socialism: industry run by guilds; G. D. H. Cole.
- Syndicalism: trade unions control industry.
- Democratic socialism: reform through the ballot, not radical change.
Fabians believed in the inevitability of gradualness. Guild socialists wanted workers to be represented by profession. Syndicalists trusted direct action by unions. Democratic socialists reject revolution and win change through elections.
| Type | Method or aim |
|---|---|
| Fabianism | Peaceful, gradual change |
| Guild socialism | Representation by profession |
| Syndicalism | Trade union control |
| Democratic socialism | Reform by ballot |
Test yourself: Which pair is NOT correct?
- Fabianism - peaceful change
- Guild socialism - professional representation
- Syndicalism - trade unionism
- Democratic socialism - radical change
Answer: D. Democratic socialism works through the ballot.
🗳️ Democracy
Liberal, social, participatory, deliberative and cosmopolitan democracy, and the classic critiques.
Models of democracy
Liberal and social democracy
Liberal democracy joins majority rule with limits on power. Social democracy adds welfare.
- Liberal democracy: government by consent, accountability, constitutional government.
- It rests on private property and markets.
- Social democracy mixes liberal freedom and socialist equality.
- Neo-corporatism: state, labour and business bargain over policy.
In a liberal democracy rulers answer to the people and are bound by a constitution. It is not designed for socialism. Social democracy accepts the market but corrects it by welfare, tax and public services. Scandinavia is the usual model.
| Model | Core idea |
|---|---|
| Liberal | Consent plus limits on power |
| Social | Liberal freedom with socialist equality |
Test yourself: Which is a principle of liberal democracy?
- Suitable for socialism
- Government by consent
- Rule by a committed judiciary
- Single party rule
Answer: B. Consent, accountability and constitutional government define it.
Essential conditions and Dewey
Democracy needs liberty, equality and an independent judiciary. Dewey called it a way of living.
- Essential conditions: liberty, equality, independent judiciary.
- A committed judiciary is not a condition.
- Dewey: democracy is a mode of associated living.
- Source: Democracy and Education, 1916.
A judiciary loyal to the ruling party removes the check that democracy needs. Dewey said democracy is more than a form of government. It is a way of living together, with shared interests and free communication.
Test yourself: Which is NOT an essential condition of democracy?
- Liberty
- Equality
- Independence of judiciary
- Committed judiciary
Answer: D. A committed judiciary destroys the check on government.
Participatory and deliberative democracy
Participatory democrats want citizens to take part. Deliberative democrats want them to reason together.
- Participatory: Pateman, Barber, Macpherson.
- Deliberative: Habermas, Joshua Cohen.
- Deliberative legitimacy needs free and reasoned agreement among equals.
- Deliberation uses public reason, not only votes.
Carole Pateman wrote Participation and Democratic Theory (1970). Benjamin Barber wrote Strong Democracy (1984). Macpherson proposed layers of direct and indirect participation. Joshua Cohen described deliberative democracy as a pluralistic association of free and equal members.
| Model | Names |
|---|---|
| Participatory | Pateman, Barber, Macpherson |
| Deliberative | Habermas, Joshua Cohen |
Test yourself: Who is associated with participatory democracy?
- Ian Shapiro
- Jurgen Habermas
- Carole Pateman
- Robert Dahl
Answer: C. Pateman, Barber and Macpherson are the participatory democrats.
Cosmopolitan democracy and critiques
Kant's ideas support democracy beyond borders. Rousseau criticised representation.
- Kant, Perpetual Peace (1795): federation of free states and world citizenship.
- Held and Archibugi build modern cosmopolitan democracy.
- Rousseau: the English are free only during elections.
- Fukuyama saw liberal democracy as final.
Rousseau held that sovereignty cannot be represented. People are free only when they vote and slaves afterwards. Cosmopolitan democrats want decisions on global problems to include affected people everywhere.
Test yourself: Who said that England is democratic only during elections?
- Voltaire
- Carlyle
- Rousseau
- Churchill
Answer: C. He said the English are free only at election time.
Polyarchy and Dahl
Dahl says no large state is a full democracy. Real systems are polyarchies.
- Polyarchy: rule by the many through competition and participation.
- Features: elected officials, free and fair elections, inclusive suffrage.
- Also freedom of expression and independent associations.
- Books: A Preface to Democratic Theory; Polyarchy (1971).
Dahl set high ideals of democracy and then showed that modern states only approach them. He called such states polyarchies. Easton, Schumpeter and Huntington are not linked with the word.
Test yourself: Who described modern democracies as polyarchies?
- Easton
- Dahl
- Schumpeter
- Huntington
Answer: B. Dahl introduced the term.
Liberal and representative democracy features
Liberal democracy limits power. Representative democracy lets citizens elect rulers.
- Liberal democracy: rule of law, civil liberties, checks and balances.
- It needs many parties and free media.
- One-party rule and state control of mass media are not part of it.
- Representative democracy suits large countries and links rulers to the ruled.
A and E are false for liberal democracy because it needs competition and a free press. In representative democracy, the people elect representatives, so the gap between rulers and people remains. Removing that gap is the aim of direct democracy. A classless society is a Marxist goal.
Test yourself: Which is NOT part of liberal democracy?
- Rule of law
- Civil liberties
- Checks and balances
- One-party system
Answer: D. Liberal democracy needs competing parties.
👩 Feminism
Waves, schools and the books and thinkers questions keep returning to.
Waves and schools
Feminist waves
Feminism grew in stages. Each stage had a different main focus.
- First wave: right to vote.
- Second wave: social and economic equality.
- Third wave: culture, difference, influence of post-structuralism.
- Later: ecofeminism links women and nature.
The order is A, B, C, D in the December 2021 item. Third wave feminism came in the 1990s. It challenged the idea of a single universal woman and drew on Foucault, Derrida and Butler.
| Wave | Focus |
|---|---|
| First | Vote |
| Second | Social and economic equality |
| Third | Culture, difference |
| Later | Ecofeminism |
Test yourself: The Third Wave of Feminism reflected the influence of
- Post-structuralism
- Anarchism
- Liberalism
- Multiculturalism
Answer: A. It was shaped by post-structuralist thinkers.
Schools of feminism
Feminists differ on the cause of inequality and on the cure.
- Liberal: equal rights and law reform. Wollstonecraft, Okin.
- Radical: patriarchy as a power system. Millett, Firestone, MacKinnon.
- Black: rejects universal sisterhood. hooks, Davis, Crenshaw.
- Post-colonial: women differ across regions. Mohanty, Spivak.
Universal sisterhood is the claim that all women share the same oppression. Black feminists rejected it because race and class shape experience. Crenshaw's term for this is intersectionality. Post-colonial feminism shows that differences exist among women of different parts of the world.
| School | Key idea | Names |
|---|---|---|
| Liberal | Equal rights | Wollstonecraft, Okin |
| Radical | Patriarchy | Millett, Firestone |
| Black | Race and class | hooks, Davis |
| Post-colonial | Differences among women | Mohanty, Spivak |
Test yourself: Who rejected the claim of universal sisterhood?
- Black feminists
- Radical feminists
- Liberal feminists
- Marxist feminists
Answer: A. They said it ignored race and class.
Feminist thinkers and works
Questions love author and book pairs. Learn each author with a signature book.
- Beauvoir: The Second Sex, 1949. One is not born a woman.
- Millett: Sexual Politics, 1970. Friedan: The Feminine Mystique.
- Firestone: The Dialectic of Sex. MacKinnon: Toward a Feminist Theory of the State.
- Okin: Justice, Gender and the Family. hooks: Feminism Is for Everybody.
Wollstonecraft's A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792) answers Rousseau's Sophie in Emile. Gilligan wrote In a Different Voice on the ethics of care. Kristeva wrote Powers of Horror. Cixous is linked with ecriture feminine. Francoise d'Eaubonne coined ecofeminism in 1974.
| Author | Work |
|---|---|
| Beauvoir | The Second Sex |
| Millett | Sexual Politics |
| Friedan | The Feminine Mystique |
| Firestone | The Dialectic of Sex |
| Gilligan | In a Different Voice |
Test yourself: Who wrote Sexual Politics?
- Kate Millett
- Simone de Beauvoir
- Betty Friedan
- Shulamith Firestone
Answer: A. Millett wrote it in 1970.
Ethics of care
Gilligan and Noddings set care against justice. Care stresses relationships.
- Justice thinking: impartial rules and rights.
- Care thinking: responsibility and attention to particular people.
- Gilligan: In a Different Voice, 1982.
- Care theorists say reason has been used to justify prejudice.
The December 2022 item had both Assertion and Reason true, with the reason explaining the assertion. The ethics of care is a moral approach contrasted with justice.
Test yourself: Who wrote In a Different Voice?
- Carol Gilligan
- Kate Millett
- Julia Kristeva
- Helene Cixous
Answer: A. Gilligan introduced the ethics of care.
Women's values and the US women's movement
Feminists say society, not biology, shapes women's values. The US movement began in 1848.
- Beauvoir: one is not born, but becomes, a woman.
- Women's values come from prescribed social roles.
- Seneca Falls Convention, 1848.
- National Woman Suffrage Association, 1869. Nineteenth Amendment, 1920.
Girls are taught to care and obey, boys to lead, and this socialisation shapes values. Feminists therefore reject the idea that biology explains women's place. In the US, the 1848 convention began the movement. The 1920 amendment gave the vote to women. The history of black women was not first narrated by Greta Thunberg.
| Event | Year |
|---|---|
| Seneca Falls Convention | 1848 |
| National Woman Suffrage Association | 1869 |
| Nineteenth Amendment | 1920 |
Test yourself: When did the Seneca Falls Convention take place?
- 1848
- 1869
- 1920
- 1949
Answer: A. It marked the birth of the US women's rights movement.
🌍 Newer debates
Multiculturalism, ecology and postmodernism: three late-twentieth-century challenges to older theories.
Multiculturalism
Kymlicka, Parekh and Taylor
Multiculturalism asks how states should treat cultural groups.
- Kymlicka: Multicultural Citizenship, 1995.
- Group rights: self-government, polyethnic, special representation.
- Internal restrictions limit members. External protections shield the group.
- Metics: resident immigrants never allowed to become citizens.
- Parekh: Rethinking Multiculturalism, 2000. Taylor: politics of recognition.
Kymlicka says minority cultures need group-differentiated rights as well as individual rights. A right to speedy trial is an individual right, not a group right. Parekh sees humans as culturally embedded and asks for intercultural dialogue.
| Thinker | Work | Idea |
|---|---|---|
| Kymlicka | Multicultural Citizenship | Group rights |
| Parekh | Rethinking Multiculturalism | Intercultural dialogue |
| Taylor | Politics of Recognition | Recognition |
Test yourself: Which is NOT a group right in Kymlicka's scheme?
- Self-government
- Polyethnic
- Special representation
- Speedy trial
Answer: D. Speedy trial is an ordinary individual right.
Ecology
Ecologism and deep ecology
Ecology studies the household of nature. Green thought splits into shallow and deep.
- Ecology: Greek oikos and logos. Haeckel coined it in 1866.
- Naess divided ecologism into shallow and deep in 1973.
- Dobson: environmentalism manages, ecologism changes values.
- Shallow ecology is reformist and anthropocentric; deep is ecocentric.
- Shallow ecologists want health, prosperity and sustainable growth for people.
Shallow or reformist ecology works inside capitalist modernity. It treats damage as an externality. Deep ecology rejects anthropocentrism and values nature in itself. The Gaia hypothesis of Lovelock treats the Earth as one self-regulating organism.
| Type | View |
|---|---|
| Shallow | Fix pollution inside the system |
| Deep | Change values; nature has its own worth |
Test yourself: Who coined the term deep ecology?
- Garrett Hardin
- Rachel Carson
- Arne Naess
- James Lovelock
Answer: C. Arne Naess in 1973.
Ecofeminism and green works
Ecofeminism links the domination of women and nature. Green books are common matches.
- Francoise d'Eaubonne coined ecofeminism in 1974.
- Vandana Shiva: Indian voice of ecofeminism.
- Silent Spring: Rachel Carson, 1962.
- The Death of Nature: Carolyn Merchant, 1980.
- Tragedy of the Commons: Garrett Hardin, 1968.
The same patriarchal outlook is said to dominate women and nature. Imagined Communities by Benedict Anderson sits in this match list but is about nationalism. E. F. Schumacher is linked with ecologism in the June 2024 match.
| Work or idea | Thinker |
|---|---|
| Silent Spring | Rachel Carson |
| Deep ecology | Arne Naess |
| Tragedy of the Commons | Garrett Hardin |
| Imagined Communities | Benedict Anderson |
Test yourself: Who wrote Silent Spring?
- Rachel Carson
- Arne Naess
- Garrett Hardin
- Vandana Shiva
Answer: A. Carson wrote it in 1962.
Postmodernism
Postmodernism and its thinkers
Postmodernists distrust grand theories. They say knowledge is tied to power.
- Lyotard: incredulity toward metanarratives.
- Lyotard: The Postmodern Condition, language games.
- Derrida: deconstruction. Foucault: power and knowledge.
- Jameson: postmodernism as the cultural logic of late capitalism.
- Postmodernists deny objective knowledge; modernism is their target.
Postmodernists reject the faith of liberals and positivists in the superiority of science. They accept pluralism and many voices. Marcuse belongs to the Frankfurt School. John Burton is a pluralist, not a postmodernist.
| Thinker | Known for |
|---|---|
| Lyotard | Incredulity toward metanarratives |
| Derrida | Deconstruction |
| Foucault | Power and knowledge |
| Rorty | Pragmatism |
Test yourself: Who is NOT a postmodern thinker?
- Lyotard
- Foucault
- Rorty
- Marcuse
Answer: D. Marcuse belongs to the Frankfurt School.
What counts as a postmodern feature
Postmodernism doubts grand theories and fixed truth. Some marks are asked as odd-one-out.
- Deconstruction (Derrida) and incredulity towards metanarratives (Lyotard).
- A challenge to accepted theories of international relations.
- Deconstruction of totality; stress on consumption and images.
- Not a feature: femininity as a core concern, or a historical tendency.
Postmodernists reject the idea that history moves towards one goal, so a historical tendency is not a postmodern mark. Femininity is a theme of feminism, not a basic postmodern feature, though feminists borrow from it.
Test yourself: Which is NOT a feature of postmodernism?
- Deconstruction
- Incredulity towards metanarratives
- Challenge to accepted IR theory
- Concern with femininity
Answer: D. Femininity is a feminist theme, not a basic mark.
Thinkers and books
Books and authors that keep returning
Several matching items test authors against books. Learn the pairs.
- Monbiot: The Age of Consent. Albert: Parecon.
- Derrida: Spectres of Marx. Klein: No Logo.
- Hayek: Constitution of Liberty. Raphael: Problems of Political Philosophy.
- Hobhouse: Elements of Social Justice. Barker: Principles of Social and Political Theory.
Other pairs: Sartori with demo-protect and demo-power, Morris with the Physical Quality of Life Index, Hayek with catallaxy and Popper with falsification. Chomsky wrote Syntactic Structures, American Power and the New Mandarins and The New Military Humanism.
| Thinker | Idea or work |
|---|---|
| Sartori | Demo-protect, demo-power |
| Morris | Physical Quality of Life Index |
| Hayek | Catallaxy |
| Popper | Falsification |
Test yourself: Who is associated with the concept of falsification?
- Sartori
- Morris
- Hayek
- Popper
Answer: D. Popper said a theory must be open to refutation.
Civil disobedience, Nozick's essay and ideology matches
Some one-line questions name an author for an essay. Learn the pair.
- Thoreau: Civil Disobedience (1849), first called Resistance to Civil Government.
- Nozick: the article "The Zigzag of Politics" in Socratic Puzzles.
- Pluralism: James Madison. Utilitarianism: Bentham.
- Integral Humanism: Deendayal Upadhyaya. Positivism: Comte.
Thoreau refused a poll tax in protest and spent a night in jail. His essay inspired Gandhi and King. Nozick is better known for Anarchy, State, and Utopia. Madison argued for balance among many groups in Federalist No. 10.
| Ideology | Proponent |
|---|---|
| Pluralism | James Madison |
| Utilitarianism | Jeremy Bentham |
| Integral Humanism | Deendayal Upadhyaya |
| Positivism | Auguste Comte |
Test yourself: Who wrote the essay Civil Disobedience?
- Herbert Marcuse
- James Tully
- Henry David Thoreau
- Bell Hooks
Answer: C. Thoreau wrote it in 1849.
Practise Political Theory
All 167 past questions in this unit, with full explanations.
Practise this unit