UGC NET Logical Reasoning: Syllogism, Fallacies and Nyaya
UGC NET Paper 1 Unit 6 explained from past questions: square of opposition, syllogism rules, fallacies, Nyaya hetvabhasa and the templates NTA repeats.
Unit 6 is the most repeated unit in Paper 1. The questions come in templates, and the templates are few. If you learn the rules below and practise the templates, this unit gives steady, rule-based marks. All counts come from JRFSmart's tagged bank of Paper 1 papers. The examples are rewritten with new terms, because the rules are what NTA tests, not the words.
What NTA asks
JRFSmart tagged 689 Unit 6 questions across 131 papers (5.3 per paper). In the wider count of 149 papers, the topics are:
| Topic | Appears in (of 149 papers) | Questions |
|---|---|---|
| Indian logic (Nyaya) | 134 | 207 |
| Fallacies | 102 | 122 |
| Square of opposition | 66 | 92 |
| Immediate inference | 53 | 54 |
| Syllogism | 41 | 47 |
| Arguments (truth, validity, analogy) | 37 | 45 |
| Coding-decoding | 28 | 28 |
| Denotation and connotation | 22 | 23 |
Another number matters. 47 groups of near-repeat questions sit in this unit, the most of any unit. These are the templates:
| Template (the question NTA keeps asking) | Papers | First and last seen |
|---|---|---|
| "Which statements are logically equivalent?" (S, P and their negations) | 27 | Oct 2022 to Jan 2026 |
| "If 'All X are Y' is true, what can be inferred?" | 23 | Nov 2021 to Jun 2026 |
| "Propositions that cannot both be false but may both be true" (subcontraries) | 17 | Dec 2019 to Jun 2026 |
| "Two premises, four conclusions: which are valid?" | 9 | Dec 2018 onward |
| "Take E as true and I as false. Pick the correct statement" | 8 | Nov 2021 to Jan 2025 |
| "'Sound is eternal because it is produced' is fallacious because..." (Nyaya) | 8 | Oct 2022 to Jan 2026 |
| "Name the fallacy: No A are B; some C are not B; so..." | 7 | Dec 2021 to Dec 2023 |
Only the terms change from paper to paper (cats and dogs become actors and comedians). Learn the template, not the words. Note that 114 of the 220 "Which is NOT correct" questions in Paper 1 are in Unit 6, so read the stem twice.
1. Square of opposition and immediate inference
There are four propositions. A: All S are P. E: No S is P. I: Some S are P. O: Some S are not P.
| Pair | Name | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| A and O, E and I | Contradictories | Always opposite. One true means the other false, and the reverse |
| A and E | Contraries | Cannot both be true; both may be false |
| I and O | Subcontraries | Cannot both be false; both may be true |
| A to I, E to O | Subalternation | If the top is true, the one below is true. If the lower is false, the top is false |
Template 1: truth given, find what follows. *If "All lions are carnivores" is given as true, which can be validly inferred? (a) "No lions are carnivores" is false. (b) "Some lions are carnivores" is true. (c) "Some lions are not carnivores" is true. (d) "Some lions are not carnivores" is false.*
- A is true. The contrary E is false, so (a) holds.
- Subalternation: I is true, so (b) holds.
- The contradictory O is false. So (c) fails and (d) holds.
- Answer: a, b and d only. Check by thinking of lions: all of them are carnivores, so no lion escapes the class, and some certainly are in it.
Template 2: "E is true and I is false". E true makes I false (contradictories), A false (contraries), O true (subalternation). Memory aid: draw the square once and write T and F on its corners.
Template 3: equivalence by conversion, obversion and contraposition. *Which are equivalent to "No poets are traders"? (1) No traders are poets. (2) All poets are non-traders. (3) No poets are non-traders. (4) All non-traders are non-poets.*
- Conversion of E: "No traders are poets". ✓ (1)
- Obversion of E: "All poets are non-traders". ✓ (2)
- (3) "No poets are non-traders" says every poet is a trader. ✗
- (4) is the contrapositive of "All poets are traders". ✗
- Answer: (1) and (2) only.
| Proposition | Converse | Obverse | Contrapositive |
|---|---|---|---|
| A: All S are P | Some P are S (limited) | No S are non-P | All non-P are non-S |
| E: No S is P | No P is S | All S are non-P | Some non-P are not non-S (limited) |
| I: Some S are P | Some P are S | Some S are not non-P | none |
| O: Some S are not P | none | Some S are non-P | Some non-P are not non-S |
2. Syllogism
A categorical syllogism has three terms. Six rules decide validity:
- The middle term must be distributed at least once.
- A term distributed in the conclusion must be distributed in its premise.
- Two negative premises give no conclusion.
- A negative premise needs a negative conclusion, and the reverse.
- Two particular premises give no conclusion.
- A particular premise needs a particular conclusion.
Distribution: A distributes the subject; E distributes both terms; I distributes none; O distributes the predicate.
Example (own terms). *Premises: All teachers are graduates. Some graduates are artists. Conclusions: (i) Some teachers are artists. (ii) Some artists are graduates.* In the first premise "graduates" is the predicate of an A proposition, so it is undistributed. In the second it is the subject of an I proposition, so it is undistributed again. The middle term is never distributed, so (i) is invalid. (ii) is the plain conversion of the second premise. Answer: (ii) only.
3. Fallacies
The Paper 1 fallacy questions ask you to name the fallacy in a short argument. The most repeated informal fallacies, counted by papers: begging the question (14 papers), appeal to ignorance (8), composition (7), division (7), whole-to-part inference (6) and affirming the consequent (4).
| Fallacy | What it does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Begging the question | The conclusion is hidden inside the premise | "The rule is fair because fair rules are right" |
| Appeal to ignorance | "Not proved false, so true" | "No one has shown ghosts do not exist, so they do" |
| Composition | What is true of the parts is said true of the whole | "Each player is skilled, so the team is the best" |
| Division | What is true of the whole is said true of each part | "The college is rich, so every teacher is rich" |
| Hasty generalisation | A rule from too few cases | "Two rude drivers, so all drivers are rude" |
| Affirming the consequent | If P then Q; Q; so P | "If it rains the road is wet. It is wet. So it rained" |
For syllogisms the formal fallacies are named by the rule broken: undistributed middle, illicit major and illicit minor, exclusive premises and four terms.
Example (own terms): illicit major. *All doctors are graduates. No clerks are doctors. So no clerks are graduates.* The term "graduates" is not distributed in the first premise, because it is the predicate of an A proposition. In the conclusion, which is an E proposition, it is distributed. Rule 2 is broken: illicit major.
Example: exclusive premises. *No fish are mammals. Some pets are not mammals. So some pets are not fish.* Both premises are negative (rule 3). The fallacy is exclusive premises.
4. Indian logic (Nyaya)
This is the most repeated topic in Paper 1 (134 of 149 papers). Learn five short lists.
The four pramanas of Nyaya: pratyaksha (perception), anumana (inference), upamana (comparison) and shabda (testimony). The Charvaka school accepts only perception. The Prabhakara Mimamsa school adds arthapatti (postulation). Bhatta Mimamsa and Advaita add anupalabdhi (non-perception) as well. Among the 170 Indian logic questions in the bank, 13 mention arthapatti and 6 mention anupalabdhi.
The five-membered syllogism: pratijna (proposition), hetu (reason), udaharana (example), upanaya (application), nigamana (conclusion). Compare it with Aristotle's three propositions: Nyaya has five, Aristotle has three.
Three terms: paksha (minor, "the hill"), sadhya (major, "fire") and hetu or linga (middle, "smoke"). Vyapti is the invariable link between hetu and sadhya.
The five hetvabhasa (fallacies of the reason):
| Hetvabhasa | Meaning | Textbook example |
|---|---|---|
| Savyabhichara | Irregular reason: it is found with and without the sadhya (too wide, too narrow or non-exclusive) | "Sound is eternal because it is knowable" |
| Viruddha | Contradictory: the reason proves the opposite | "Sound is eternal because it is produced" |
| Satpratipaksha | Counter-balanced: a reason of equal force proves the opposite | "Sound is eternal because it is audible" against "Sound is non-eternal because it is produced" |
| Asiddha | Unproved: the reason is not in the subject | "The sky-lotus is fragrant because it is a lotus" |
| Badhita | Contradicted by other proof | "Fire is cold because it is a substance" |
Template (8 papers): *"Sound is eternal, because it is produced" is fallacious because...* The reason "produced" is found only in non-eternal things. So it proves the opposite of the thesis. This is viruddha: the middle term disproves the original proposition and proves its contradictory.
5. Arguments, intension and extension
- Valid means the conclusion must follow if the premises are true. Sound means valid and the premises are actually true. An inductive argument is strong or weak; strong with true premises is cogent. Truth belongs to statements; validity belongs to arguments.
- Intension (connotation) is the set of qualities. Extension (denotation) is the set of things. More qualities, fewer things. In increasing intension: vehicle, car, sports car. The same order is a decreasing extension. In papers, "order by intension" came up repeatedly (22 papers touch this topic).
Decision rules
| If the question says... | Do this |
|---|---|
| "X is true; what can be inferred" | Draw the square; write T or F on each corner |
| "logically equivalent" | Convert, obvert or contrapose; keep only exact matches |
| "cannot both be false" | Subcontraries (I and O) |
| "cannot both be true, may both be false" | Contraries (A and E) |
| two premises, many conclusions | Check the middle term first |
| "name the fallacy" in a syllogism | Count negatives first, then check distribution |
| "reason proves the opposite" | Viruddha |
| "reason found in the subject? no" | Asiddha |
| "NOT" in the stem | Mark the one false item |
Practise with 25 Unit 6 questions. Use the Unit 6 mind map and the Unit 6 page. To see how NTA recycles questions, read how NTA repeats questions with one word changed. For the full ranked topic list, see most repeated Paper 1 topics.
Frequently asked questions
Which logical reasoning topics are asked most in UGC NET Paper 1?
Indian logic (Nyaya) in 134 of 149 papers, fallacies in 102, the square of opposition in 66, immediate inference in 53 and syllogism in 41. These five cover most of Unit 6.
How many logical reasoning questions are in UGC NET Paper 1?
About 5 per paper. Unit 6 averaged 5.3 questions across the 131 papers in our bank, the second-highest of the ten units after ICT and level with Data Interpretation.
Does NTA repeat logical reasoning questions?
Yes, more than any other unit. JRFSmart found 47 groups of near-repeat questions in Unit 6. One question about logical equivalence came back, with only the terms changed, in 27 papers.
What are the five hetvabhasa?
Savyabhichara (irregular reason), viruddha (contradictory reason), satpratipaksha (counter-balanced reason), asiddha (unproved reason) and badhita (contradicted reason). These are the five fallacies of the middle term in Nyaya.
How do I know a syllogism is valid?
Check the middle term is distributed at least once, no term is distributed in the conclusion unless it was distributed in its premise, and two negative premises or two particular premises give no conclusion.
Related guides
Turn this into marks
Practise real past-paper questions with full explanations. Free to start, no card needed.
Practise 25 free questionsOpen the mind map for this unitBrowse every UGC NET topic